MovieChat Forums > Lilting (2014) Discussion > Generally, very good (spoilers)

Generally, very good (spoilers)


It did look like I was going to be the only person at the showing at Leicester's Phoenix last night... In the last couple of minutes, a few more people did wander in. But, there could have barely been a dozen of us and I felt the film deserved a considerably larger audience... That's not to say it's perfect... The dialogue is occasionally a bit clunky - "Sniff my armpit again!" is particularly jarring... There seems to be a bit of confusion about how many years Junn has been in the country and whether she could have really managed to pick up so little English... The characters remain a little anonymous in some respects... For example, what does Richard do for a living..? We find out he's good at cooking - is he a chef..? I suppose this might be intentional - allowing the audience to pick up only scraps of information, as someone who doesn't speak the language of those surrounding them might... And, I didn't find the ending hugely satisfying and wonder if the director has been heavily influenced by French cinema, where that sort of non-ending is common... However, I really did like it very much... Interesting, moving and, occasionally, gently amusing... To be honest, I felt that Peter Bowles seemed to be in a slightly different film. But, Naomi Christie is very good and Ben Whishaw, Andrew Leung and Cheng Pei Pei are mesmerising!

reply

I wuz only person in theater...I guess there wuz another mystery person somewhere in back but didn't wanna find out who dat wuz...it wuz kinda scarie...scaaaaaaaaarie. Anyway, da movie sux.

Werd 2 ur mudda, bruddafckka

reply

In my area I doubt their will be a seat available. Not because of lots of gays, which there are, but because Ben has such an undeniable presence on screen and is able to fluidly move between sexes as partners in films which is, by the way, a phenomenal accomplishment in film history.

GFW ✨

reply

I think Junn's lack of English was explained by her son having a go at her for choosing not to embrace English culture at all in the time she's lived there - there is no helping people like that.

However, for the girl to have to translate simple words and phrases like 'Yes' and 'No' for Junn was a stretch.

"Please don't eat me! I have a wife and kids. Eat them!"

reply