MovieChat Forums > Crimson Peak (2015) Discussion > I am convinced that no horror movie is a...

I am convinced that no horror movie is actually scary


Im 15 and I can honestly say I have never seen a scary horror movie. Ive seen many of the Films people call the scariest of all time i watched without feeling anything/even laughing at times.Ive seen among many others all the friday the 13th's, nightmare on elm street, salo, serbian film, childs play, paranormal activity, saw I still enjoy watching horror movies because they are usually entertaining but I don't scream and run out of the room like some of my friends do.

Posting this just cuz I saw this film and santa sangre over halloween and I found neither of them particularly frightening after my friends told me it was scary.

reply

I can somewhat sympathise with you, as someone who loves horror films but very rarely find any of them scary. Having said that, you should know that none of the movies you mentioned are considered very scary by most horror fans. Serbian Film and Salo are certainly known for being disturbing, but not really scary, and the others are all more fun than they are frightening. I would think that you've seen The Shining and Alien, but if you haven't, you should check them out. You probably won't find them terrifying, but there are some suspenseful parts in them. Funny Games and the Hitcher both have very creepy villains, and Suspiria is also worth a watch if you haven't seen it. Another movie I would suggest, which isn't really a horror film but quite dark in places anyway, is Blue Velvet. And if you like that, check out Lynch's series 'Twin Peaks' , but it's al long watch and you may not be up for it.

reply

Blue Velvet is the only movie I've ever seen that can change genre depending on mood and setting. Twin Peaks is a bit like that as well, I suppose it's what makes Lynch the greatest director of all time (IMO of course)

reply

Telling a 15 year old to look into Lynch, thats funny.

reply

You are correct - I love horror, but I haven't been genuinely scared by one since I watched the Shining at 11/12 years old. The films that have got under my skin since then have not been horror as such, the two that stand out would be the nuclear war drama Threads and the Russian film Come and See about the Nazi pograms (which is surreal, nightmarish and genuinely horrifying).

"To err is human...so...errrr..." - Gary King

reply

Well. Yeah you're watching the fast food of horror movies. If I only went to McDonald's, I'd probably say that I never ate a good burger in my whole life and therefore, all burgers are disgusting.

A Nightmare on Elm Street, only the first one, was made at the beginning of the 1980s. It's hard to scare new audiences with 30-year-old movies, because the special effects are obviously not as great. But that's not the reason why ANOES and Halloween are classics. It's because they are very unique in the atmosphere they manage to create. Whether you find Freddy scary or not is another story.

And in those two movies, it's not what you see that is deemed scary, but the whole idea behind it all. In one movie, you have an ex-child murderer who was burned alive by angry parents and who came back to hunt the children in their dreams, where they can't escape and they can't fight back. That, to me, is as scary as it gets. Then, in the second movie (the original, not the remake), you have a 6-year-old child who, one day and for no apparent reason, picks up a knife and kills his sister and her boyfriend. Then he goes to an asylum. I find asylums extremely creepy btw. He eventually escapes and goes back to finish what he started and kill the rest of his family. That's a pretty scary idea too.

I think the problem is that while watching the movie, you don't lose yourself in it and you keep thinking to yourself: "Ok that's fake". If I watch a comedy and I start wondering whether each joke is funny or not, I'm probably not gonna laugh either.

But you should watch psychological horror. This might be more your thing. You named a lot of horror porn in your list. I am not scared by face blood and guts either. Try Oculus. The Others and The Babadook are great movies too. And I liked 1408 with John Cusack. Stop watching junk man.

reply

Very nice post. It is also worth noting horror isn't necessarily meant to scare.


Film Reverie: http://filmreverie.blogspot.com.au/
My film diary: http://letterboxd.com/filmreverie/

reply

I rarely get scared while watching horror movies any longer. Sometimes they do get me though.

I watched Sinister alone in the middle of the night awhile back.
It was a very dreadful experience.

Watching movies alone on a TV in your body is one of the best settings for horror movies. Doing it with friends or over a computer takes away alot of the experience in my opinion.

If movies don't work, try playing a horror all alone in the middle of the night. Something like PT, Layers of Fear or Amnesia.
Impossible to not get scared while doing it through gameplay.

reply

Movies don't scare me at all, however playing games like Amnesia at night with earphones, now THAT makes me crap my pants!!

reply

I refuse to believe people that say they didn't find Paranormal Activity scary.

Utah! Get me two.

reply

Cabinet doors opening on their own in night vision isn't scary. To each their own but imho Paranormal Activity was garbage and not scary.

reply

I refuse to believe people that say they find Paranormal Activity scary.


Fixed it for you. Paranormal Activity not only wasn't scary, it was boring.

reply

This.

For a movie to be scary, it has to somehow tap into one's innate fears. Jaws, Vertigo, Alien, and Nightmare on Elm Street all tap into fears that resonate. A good horror movie lets the viewer build his own fears out of his imagination.

I cannot suspend my disbelief for Paranormal Activity. And that leaves the whole thing looking silly.

As for Crimson Peak, it started out well, but the third act was quite disappointing. And was this supposed to be a ghost story or a serial killer story or a Gothic romance? The movie couldn't decide.

And really, Jessica Chastain is so tiny, I don't see how she could be a serial murderer. That she could beat up Edith's father in the bathroom and smash his skull on the sink isn't remotely believable.

reply

Ive seen among many others all the friday the 13th's, nightmare on elm street, salo, serbian film, childs play, paranormal activity,


Most of those are gory/disturbing films, not scary films. Paranormal Activity is just a jump flick, not a scary one.

Have you seen The Exorcist? Candyman? The Ring?

For recent ones Last Shift and Bone Tomahawk weren't too bad, though Tomahawk was more a gory/disturbing film than scary.

reply

watch SINISTER

▇ ▆ ▅ ▃ ▂ ▁ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ewVfsXIQNA ▁ ▂ ▃ ▅ ▆ ▇

reply

Yeah dude I'm 23 and a lot of it becomes desensitizing over time. I can say I've never screamed at a movie before, but definitely been shocked (I'm sure "Jaws" did something to you as a kid, go on admit it, it got us all). XD

Very glad you had seen "Santa Sangre", may I recommend you check out the previous directors work (Alejandro Jodorowsky). Surely you've seen "The Shining"? and last of all if you feel like you're up for some truly weird stuff may I recommend the works of Takashi Miike, "Audition" in particular.

Some shocking war films would be Poland's 1950's "Kanal", and 1980's Russian "Come and See". Unforgettable stuff, just don't say I didn't warn you. Happy Watching.

reply