What do you think of Jeremy@Geeks&Gamers, Dicktor Van Doomcock, Nerdrotic.com ...

I unsubscribed to Geeks and Gamers. He attacks SW fans and he thought it was OK for an SW actress to be attacked to the point of her becoming suicidal. I think he and the other vloggers are more about making money by exploiting political division, hate and inciting anger than about being a true SW fan. Politicized sites have more loyal followings (therefore more income) which is why they exploit it.

The other vloggers I don't know and if they're like him, I don't what to.

BTW, I know more positive SW vloggers who are a bit more positive and objective. I'll stick with them.

I hope SW9 is good but I doubt it will be since Disney:SW is more about making money than creating a quality movie. I prefer to be wrong, but after what they did to Luke and the EU, I doubt it. The Mandalorian and the video game look more promising.

Fandom Menace , they are just as bad as Lucasflim

Doomcock does 5+ hour youtoob rants wearing a Styrofoam mask! Google pays him for this!!!
Charlie Manson is more informative than this shit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4LwGTp9wleE

I agree with them in general: the new Star Wars is inferior and seems like the product of focus groups and misused analytics from social media. But Doomcock and nerdrotic get so damned dramatic and angry that it gets silly. Then in general I really get turned off when they get quasi political and their rants spill over into so-called “SJW/liberal media” etc etc blah blah blah, that’s where they’re getting in over their head.
I still give nerdrotic a fair chance but generally the idea that there’s an entire wing of YouTube that is trying to make a career out of making foaming at the mouth rants about Star Wars just seems silly.

They are called The Fandom Menace, and by organizing the boycott of "Solo" they have done more for Star Wars fans than Disney ever will. Hail The Fandom Menace!

I do not subscribe to them and when I do see their videos I watch and take what they say with a grain of salt. Of the 3 you mentioned, Nerdrotic.com is the only one that I think maintains some balance (or at least tries to). The other 2 are clearly aiming for going over the top. I agree with some of what they say and disagree with other stuff.

I actually hope they are not wasting their time though. I have very much disliked the new trilogy so far, and except for Rogue One have not like a single Disney Star Wars product. If some over the top vloggers can inspire enough consumers to take their money and spend it elsewhere perhaps in the future there will be a Star Wars product that I actually enjoy again.

I am not 'joining' them in their calls for boycotts. I am just not going to see these movies in theater, haven't been already since TFA. Maybe the product will shift to be more for me again in the future. If not, if it still makes money clearly it is a product that consumers want and I wish them all the best. It just do not like the product anymore.

WorldClassBullshitters is by far the best of the bunch when it comes to "The Fandom Menace".

[deleted]