MovieChat Forums > High Maintenance (2012) Discussion > Broad City, Girls, and High Maintenance

Broad City, Girls, and High Maintenance


Rank these shows from best to worst.



reply

Wait, these are different shows? ;)

reply

It's not that easy to rank them because Broad City, in my opinion, has really gone down in quality. I thought the first season was just hilarious, but the second season really had only one funny scene in it and the rest was just meh, and the third season was just totally unfunny. It's obvious that they are out of ideas. I am not going to watch that show anymore.

I only watched the first season of Girls. The thing about it for me was that I watched for as long as it seemed real, and when in the season finale it suddenly turned out that that guy was actually in love with Lena and wanted to get married (or something, I no longer remember the exact details) - that didn't strike me as real at all, and I just lost interest. I tried watching season 2, but it didn't take.

It's only been 5 episodes of High Maintenance so far, and I would say it's a bit hit or miss, but I am willing to give it a chance. As of right this moment, this is the best show IMO out of the three.


reply

You're commenting on the thread for the web series that made this show possible for an HBO pick up, which I consider the web series version of HM even better than the HBO series.

Also, you're completely wrong about Broad City to the point of me being confused af as to how you came to that conclusion. Were we even watching the same show?? Because the show I watched was hilarious each episode and each season has been a improvement from the last..

reply

Also, you're completely wrong about Broad City

Preferences can't be "wrong". To me it wasn't funny.

Do you always say to people who don't like the same movies/ music/ TV shows as you that they are wrong??


reply

They're all great ..all very differenté so can't compare.

reply

Havent seen Girls but agreed, they're too different to compare anyway

reply