MovieChat Forums > V/H/S/2 (2013) Discussion > Rank All 11 VHS Segments

Rank All 11 VHS Segments


1. Safe Haven - 9/10
2. Second Honeymoon - 8/10
3. The Sick Thing That Happened To Emily When She Was Younger - 7.5/10
4. A Ride in the Park - 7/10
5. Tuesday the 17th - 6.5/10
6. Tape 49 - 6/10
7. Amateur Night - 5.5/10
8. 10/31/98 - 5/10
9. Clinical Trials - 4/10
10. Tape 56 - 3/10
11. Slumber Party Alien Abduction - 2/10

reply

Safe Haven
10/31/98
Amateur Night
The Sick Thing That Happened To Emily When She Was Younger
Slumber Party Alien Abduction
Tuesday The 17th
A Ride In The Park
Clinical Trials
Tape 56
Tape 49
Second Honeymoon

I liked V/H/S more than V/H/S 2, but I think V/H/S 2 has the best short (Safe Haven).

Honey Badger don't care

reply

1. Safe Haven
2. 10/31/98
3. A Ride in The Park
4. Amateur Night
5. Clinical Trials
6. The Sick Thing That Happened To Emily When She Was Younger
7. Slumber Party Alien Abduction
8. Tape 49
9. Tape 56
10. Second Honeymoon
11. Tuesday the 17th

reply

Great:

Save Haven
Amateur Night

Good:

Clinical Trials
A Ride in the Park
Second Honeymoon

Okay:

10/31/98
The Sick Thing That Happened To Emily When She Was Younger
Slumber Party Alien Abduction

Bad:

Tape 49
Tuesday the 17th
Tape 56

I enjoyed V/H/S/2 much more than the first. I would give 2 a 8/10 and 1 a 6/10. Personally though, I think doing away with the wrap-arounds and just presenting them as an anthology of shorts would do wonders for the films, and I'd probably rate them 1 point higher each without them.

reply

This is tough, as I would probably change my order depending on what I'm basing it on. For this, I decided to base it on how "creepy" and well-done it was, and not acting or the originality of the story.

1)Amateur Night
2)Clinical Trials
3)Second Honeymoon
4)Slumber Party Alien Abduction
5)Safe Haven
6)Tuesday the 17th
7)10/31/98
8)The Sick Thing That Happened to Emily...
9)Tape 49
10)A Ride in the Park
11)Tape 56

reply

Safe Heaven was the one with the monster with horns right? that was the weirdest one! My heart was really bumbing with that one.

"Light up the darkness..."

reply

PAPPA !

reply

1)Safe Haven
2)Amateur Night
3)A Ride in the Park

The rest SUCKED!

reply

1. Safe Haven
2. Amateur Night
3. 10/31/98
4. The Sick Thing That Happened To Emily When She Was Younger
5. Second Honeymoon
6. A Ride in the Park
7. Tuesday the 17th
8. Tape 49
9. Tape 56
10. Clinical Trials
11. Slumber Party Alien Abduction

6/10

Look at the night sky, where does it end?

reply

[deleted]

"I love how so many people love Amateur Night. When the original was released, critics claimed it was the overall weakest segment. "

What. Really?

I mean, I generally didn't hear much from critics on V/H/S asides from "meh, sucks" (not in those words of course). I generally heard encouraging reviews from ordinary internet users and they all made very clear that "Amateur Night" was the one to watch.

reply

1. Second Honeymoon
2. The Sick Thing That Happened To Emily When She Was Younger
3. Clinical Trials
4. Slumber Party Alien Abduction
5. Amateur Night
6. Safe Haven
7. 10/31/98
8. A Ride in the Park
9. Tuesday the 17th
10. Tape 49
11. Tape 56

reply

Horray for Second Honeymoon!

1. Amateur Night
2. Second Honeymoon
3. A Ride in the Park
4. 10/31/98
5. Tuesday the 17th
6. Safe Haven
7. Phase I Clinical Trials
8. The Sick Thing
9. SPAA
10. Tape 56
11. Tape 49

reply

safe haven was definitely the best sequence
the others were mediocre at best

reply