MovieChat Forums > Ghost Mine (2013) Discussion > How many people visit abandoned mines to...

How many people visit abandoned mines to find tommyknockers?


I haven't watched the new reality ghost-hunting show, GHOST MINE, which debuts tonight.

We all know how popular ghost-hunting and paranormal shows are today. This topic goes away and comes back throughout the public consciousness in America.

I don't know if GHOST MINES will hold a lasting public interest. Why? How many people visit abandond mines? Do mine workers see ghosts in working mines?

Ghost-hunting and ghost-research are popular because lots of people can relate. People have lived in haunted houses, visited haunted homes and locations, but just about nobody has interest in going into a dangerous, abandoned mine to ferret out human ghosts.

Yes, abandoned and open mines should be chock full of human ghosts if you accept the premise that places of human tragedy tend to attract the paranormal. Uncounted tens of thousands of human beings perished in minework throughout human history. The number is probably in the hundreds of thousands. I wouldn't be surprised if I was grossly undercounting. Dangerous mining was not always voluntary or a chosen occupation, dangerous as it still is. Human slavery manned much of pre-20th century mining. You read ancient accounts of mining where voluntary workers and slaves perished in the frequent cave-ins, explosions, oxygen deprivation, numerous fatal and mortal injuries, sheer overwork - to death, and death by violence at the hands of overseers or co-miners.

The legend of ghost miners, "tommyknockers", goes back hundreds of years so I'm sure the ghost-hunting team will find something. I'm not sure they should be there. Human ghosts being earthbound are in pain and torment; they cannot pass over or are unwilling to pass over. They need pity, compassion, prayers, and masses to help them rest in peace. Why should the living treat them like circus and carnival freak attractions, as if poking them with a stick?

reply

Jeff, that's a really interesting point you make. I love these kind of shows. Not THIS one, for the prescient points you made. But, I never thought of these ghosts as humans in pain. And that's what a lot of these "spirits" are, aren't they? Remember a few years ago there was a show on the "style" channel, I think, and the star was this big, blowsy British blonde medium? I don't remember her name. There was another show with a British blonde woman, that was really the first popular paranormal reality show, as well. But this woman was the medium, and a lot of the time she'd end up sending the troubled spirit "to the otherside", with help from her deceased brother, I think. Sometimes that happens in these ten million ghost shows, but not very often, unfortunately. Let's face it, a lot of these people, mediums or just "ghost hunters", are suspect. Wouldn't buy a used car from any of them, knowwhatimean, Vern??

There's really no reason for these multitudes to check out famous haunted places. Some of them justify themselves as "we wanna know", but if you believe in this kind of thing, how much confirmation do you need? Even after the ol' 3 scratches down the back from a Trinity-taunting demon, they're still at it. It's chasing that scare high, then getting payed well to chase after that scare high -- not that will stop me from watching some of these shows. I just won't get my own. ;p

reply

Dear jeffyoung1:

When I'm not tracking Sasquatches; you can find me in any mine taping "tommyknockers".

TRUE.

reply