MovieChat Forums > Fed Up (2014) Discussion > A message to those who blame the governm...

A message to those who blame the government/food industry ..


First of all, don't listen to people who say it is your fault for being addicted to junk food. If you're like me, you were fed this crap as a child before you ever had any say in the matter, so this isn't like hard drugs, where you pretty much have to go and seek those out. No, this addiction was given to you thanks to your parents. You would not tell a heroin addict it was their fault if they were 'fed' the drug as a child. Some things we just didn't have any control over, or else didn't know any better. But here's some food for thought ...

I used to be like a lot of you in blaming the government, blaming the food industry, and whoever else I thought might've had a hand in my addiction. But do you know what? After all that whining was done, I was still overweight and dependent on junk food. And so too will you be. I think there are steps the government should take in regulating the food industry, esp going after the psychopaths who are dressing up food labels to give consumers the impression that their products are healthy, knowing full well that they're not. There is such a thing as false advertising. There needs to be WARNING labels on anything with HCF and other poisons.

The good news though is that you don't have to wait for the government to act before you start making changes. My advice would be to work on one vice at a time. I started by giving up tobacco, followed up by alcohol. (Granted, those aren't junk food and nobody's fault but my own, but we all have to start somewhere.) At the beginning of this year, I set a goal to give up soda, and I haven't had one since Dec 31 of last year. I've also made drastic changes in the way I eat; my diet is still far from perfect, but it is a lot better than it used to be. During this process, I started exercising regularly, and I've lost about 25lbs.

So what's my point? Although it isn't your fault that you are addicted to this stuff, it is your fault if you STAY addicted. The information to make changes is out there and readily available. If I and hundreds of thousands of others can start making better choices about our health without the nanny state being involved, why can't you? Some people rightly point out that sugar is like a drug to the brain, but so what? You can give up drugs; people do it all the time. I don't even crave sodas anymore. If you say you don't have the will power, well guess what? The government lowering the sugar content in foods isn't going to make those veggies taste any better. A bag of low sugar cookies is always going to taste better than broccoli.

And don't let a bunch of morons tell you that eating healthy is more expensive. It isn't. And if it is, it's not overly so. I doubt there's anyone on this board who couldn't afford to eat healthier. I actually spend less on food than I used to, primarily because I eat a lot less of it. Why do I eat less of it? Because it doesn't taste as good :P In fact, I hate it every day. But at least I can go to bed every night, knowing I am in control of this area of my life, and don't have to depend on the nanny state to make these choices for me. Does that make me BETTER than you? Well, actually it does :P Even if you have to spend a little more to eat healthier, odds are significantly in your favor that you're going to have to spend a lot less down the road in medical expenses because of all the crap you'll no longer be putting into your body on a daily basis. Think of it as an investment in your future.

The best news of all is that what I said above about not having to wait for the government also applies to pretty much every other area of your life. Don't let those who have committed themselves to living off the government's teet for the rest of their lives keep telling you that you are a victim, because if you think you are, you always will be. Granted, there ARE some victims out there, but this doesn't apply to the majority who are whining about what the government or corporations aren't doing. While you wait for changes 'out there', take some f-king initiative for once and do something on your own!

reply

SPOILERS

Great post. I agree there needs to be more corporate responsibility, but ultimately it is in our hands. I loved the film and it is essential viewing, however the issue goes beyond simple informing. It's not like in all cases one views the film, learns sugar is bad, and then flips the switch and stops it altogether.

No doubt this will lead to action, however a bigger issue is why we as humans undertake behavior we consciously know is bad for us. Near the end when it was revealed the kid gained the weight back begs this very question, answers to which would help explain why this and other similar predicaments exist in the first place.

reply

[deleted]

You lost me right here. It's not an addiction. That's a silly thing to say. And it's even more ridiculous to compare a junk food "addict" to a heroin addict who is actually an addict.


So maybe I should've said nicotine instead of heroin? As someone who has kicked the smoking habit (which doing so was not what I would call pleasant), I can honestly say that trying to give up junk food has been even harder than that. (And by junk food, I mean anything you KNOW that isn't good for you.) In fact, I don't personally know ANYBODY who doesn't indulge from time to time, and even the people who abstain except on special occasions exercise a great amount of willpower doing so. Some people really do love fruits and veggies; I do not happen to be one of those people :P I don't have to constantly shake off the urge to smoke every day anymore, but I'm not sure my cravings for donuts and McDonalds hamburgers will ever go away. I assume it will be this way until the day I die.

So, tell me... if you keep eating/drinking this stuff despite negative health consequences and your desire to quit, how is this not an addiction? Because you're not vomiting and physically convulsing if you go without? I didn't do that with tobacco either. And how is it your fault when you were started on this stuff as a toddler? If you drink soda or eat fast food every day, could you quit cold turkey?

BTW: If you didn't read the rest of my post beyond the first couple of paragraphs, you should really do so :P

reply

[deleted]

So, if junk food and sugar are an addiction, tell me, how did I just suddenly grow out of it and give it all up for no apparent reason?


Probably for the same reason that some people do the same with hard drugs. Not all addictive substances are addictive for everyone 100% of the time. Some people try heroin and don't like it. Others get hooked after the very first hit. Still others use casually and just walk away at some point.

I think we could classify most addictions as weaknesses. An addiction won't kill you 99% of the time if you just quit cold turkey.

reply

[deleted]

Yeah, I'm not that kind of person. I have a very addictive personality and I've struggled with actual addictions (cigarettes, alcohol, cocaine). Sugar is not addictive and not comparable to actual drugs.


just because that's been your experience doesn't mean other people are the same. my sister was addicted to meth and used plenty of other drugs during that time, and has now been clean for over 9 years -- yet she still struggles with food addiction on a daily basis. she is not obese, nor is she lazy in the slightest.

my brother is an alcoholic, now sober for 6 years, and has had more difficulty quitting unhealthy/sugary/"comfort" foods than alcohol. he is the physically healthiest member of our family, and not at all lazy or weak-willed.

as i said in another post of yours i just replied to, i'm not sure if you saw the movie, but they mentioned a study in which rats already supplied with cocaine were given the option of either that or sugar water. all but a few chose the sugar water, even if they were previously cocaine addicts.

reply

I think you are a condescending idiot telling the same story as the food industry, and you probably are being paid by them, if you even exists as a real person at all. This is just the kind of evil guerrilla marketing and mind control corporations are trying these days.

Your narrative is full of slogans and cliches, the very same stuff that has not worked, and basically it is all about leaving the food industry alone ... that is your own real action item ... that you support by using loaded crap terms like "nanny state".

If you are a real person, I'm glad you figured out the solution to your problem, but if you are a real person you might stop letting it be all about egotistically you and realize not everyone can or needs to take the same path as you.

You think people should do something on their own, yet you are telling everyone what to do. This message of yours is incoherent and illogical and does not follow what we now know about this. I suggest you mind your own business if you cannot be part of the real solution and do not understand science.

reply

Okay, you got me. I am a shill for the junk food industry. Busted!

reply

How many forums have been paid writers in them, seriously.

Kids are indoctrinated to consume a drug, that drug is sugar.

The film wants to change that, anyone disagrees with that is either being paid or stupid.

Pizza is a vegetable, no % on sugar for food labels. $$$

We have sugar % labels here in UK, it helps.

FYI for a treats keep the % to between 20-30 tops. The eat food that's grown or from an animal, and drink water.

I don't exercise and I eat treats, but doing above works for me.

reply

We have sugar % labels here in UK, it helps.


The most obese nation in Europe, you mean? As a British person who's lived in America for the past three years or so, there's really not that much difference between them.

But I also think the obesity epidemic is overstated. The definitions of "obesity" are pretty broad in a lot of those studies. I think I read somewhere that George Clooney would technically be considered obese by some standards.

reply

Full court propaganda press by the food industry on this board.

reply