MovieChat Forums > The Central Park Five (2014) Discussion > Everyone Needs to See This Film

Everyone Needs to See This Film


Everyone needs to see this film because New York is only one of many cities and states where this happens--young people coerced into confessing to a crime they did not commit, wasting years of their lives in prison and, when finally exonerated, the entities responsible for the wrongful conviction fight against compensating them. That is why I wrote "Accidental Felon" -- to show people how easily this could happen to them or someone they know.

Ken Burns believes race is at the heart of most injustice in the US. Read about the Chicago torture trials--innocent young Black men physically tortured to confess--and you will be convinced. But this happens regardless of race. It happened to White, young sailors in Norfolk (known as The Norfolk Four), who suffer to this day because judges (with one exception, the dissenting opinion at the 4th circuit) refuse to acknowledge their primary role is to uphold justice and fairness. Instead, they refuse to acknowledge these young men are innocent, refuse to accept DNA evidence that proves their innocence.

There will be no remedies for the injustice that is solidly part of the system until sufficient numbers of the public become outraged and demand their legislators and Congress implement change. Until then, your young adult or teen, your grandchild, your neighbor, may be the next victim of corrupt police, corrupt prosecutors, negligent judges.

reply

[deleted]

I want to seee this film because I remembered it.

"SG"

reply

i just saw it tonight. it was very, very powerful. there were parts of it that made me feel like i was suffocating. not too many movies affect me like that.

reply

Some horrible techniques used in this film, just terrible. One is total sh*t audio of a squeely tension sound throughout much of the film, while someone is talking. Ken Burns usually is a terrible film maker, but he really goes to new low of sh*t audio in this one.

The other sh*t technique he uses, which makes the film almost unwatchable and needlessly useless, is not showing who is talking. One of a dozen interviewees is talking, but is not shown at all while they're rambling on for five or ten minutes straight. Instead they show still pictures or old footage that has nothing to do at all with what the unknown person is rambling about.
Ken Burns is not known for producing anything worth watching, but he really outdoes himself with the uselessness on this one.

reply

One of the Central Park five did not want to be filmed on camera, so that is why other footage is shown. Maybe you need to pay more attention...

reply

Let me know when your documentary is finished starman.

reply

Don't forget the West Memphis Three.

reply

The Central Park Five are like the Scottsboro Boys of our time.

Jaan Pehechan Ho

reply

Regardless as to whether they were involved in the assault AND/OR rape of Meili, they were still members of the Central Park Thirty who were responsible for the assaults of upwards of ten victims that night.

This documentary was made in part to generate public sympathy towards the claims for compensation of the Five's wrongful imprisonment, something the film makers alluded to outside of the documentary.

Whilst the Five may be deserving in the compensation, against the evidence in Meili's rape only, we have no way of telling how many assaults were involved in the commission of that night, potentially including that of Meili before, during or after her rape.

Everyone has an agenda, even me, just be willing to do your own research before you let anyone tell you what 'the truth is'.

Cheers
Rowan/LSWSjr

reply

Agreed; I just watched it on Netflix. What a sad story...these kids were railroaded by a police/prosecution team eager to place the blame on innocent victims before all the facts were in!

reply

You really need to understand that what you watched was a pure propaganda film intended to manipulate you into having precisely the reaction you have expressed here.

reply

Why shouldn't people react that way?
Why don't you elaborate?

reply