hi,
once again, this is a expected happy end for this movie (it is not a good thing).
it would have been ever better if the end was really un-hollywooded !
by example, the lost track should make a reference of a extra-girlfriend or an affair the singer was in ! it would have been a better end to the grieve of the girl....
but no, this is hollywood, so all is happy in a happy world !
Totally agree...from the beginning I was fervently hoping they wouldn't "fall for each other" because it just wasn't necessary for this storyline. It actually came out of left field when he said he loved her...that just seemed ridiculous. Not a lot of progression, there. I was hoping he said something on the recording that would approximate a suicide note, or, like you, that he had an affair or SOMETHING to shake him off that pedestal. Disappointing.
shareThe widow wrote the song, it had nothing to do with suicide.
shareI was hoping he said something on the recording that would approximate a suicide note, or, like you, that he had an affair or SOMETHING to shake him off that pedestal. Disappointing.
disagree. from the moment his gorgeous gf arrived unexpectedly and he was so disappointed, SHE knew.
shareI wouldn't go as far as another girl, because that is Hollywood-y too, but would have liked the 2 main characters tp be friends and help each other through their problems as friends. He could help her move on and write the book, but they don't end up together.
The proper ending would have been Hannah losing her mind.
The song they discovered was clearly a suicide note, no question. But Hannah never could bare the thought her husband could have done something like that. She didn't want to face the obvious so she told Andrew that she wrote the song so that Andrew would just let it go.
The PERFECT ending would have been Andrew coming to look for Hannah only to find her dead right where her husband was found; aka committing the exact same suicide the husband did.
Yo momma
couldn't bear, not bare.
share