MovieChat Forums > Trudno byt bogom (2014) Discussion > This is why ratings are ridiculous

This is why ratings are ridiculous


Rating this movie a 1 is completely acceptable. Rating it a 10 is, as well. I gave it an 8 for no other reason than I will most likely never watch any part of it again. Was I disgusted? Not in the least. Was I confused? For every second of the film, until a specific moment, where the main character changes. Was I bored? Terribly. Could I look away? Not in a million years. Did I miss things throughout that made me miss key plot points? Not really, because, much like an earlier Russian film, Stalker, it's all pretty much the journey to get to the finale.

When the movie finished I gave it two stars out of five on another site. Two hours later, I gave it three. This morning, I gave it four. It will probably hover around 4-5 for the next week. Unlike a movie like Bela Tarr's The Turin Horse, I won't be as affected by this, but it will stay with me. Is it the masterpiece some are calling it? Probably. Will I ever view it as one of the great movies of all-time? Doubtful. Finally, would I recommend it? To about three people.

reply

I gave it a 10/10. It has become an instant favourite, as did The Turin Horse for that matter. Masterpieces.


Cinema is the memory of life.

reply

Turin Horse was one of the first movies I thought of while watching, but for me, there was no way I could "grade" the movie on the same level as Turin Horse. Turin Horse left me unable to watch another movie for five days. This one, had me reaching for a palate cleanser.

reply

I quite enjoyed reading your thoughts/process/conclusions. Thanks for thinking.

p.s. Still gearing up to begin the experience. Watched the first couple of minutes after a bowl, and decided that may be the way to go.

reply

I rarely partake, but looking back, that may definitely have been the way to go.

reply

I kinda feel the same way about Stalker, as you feel about this movie.. That one sat with me and really made me think about it, while this one was a battle to finish..

reply

Nice write up. Pretty much captures my feelings about the film.

reply