MovieChat Forums > I (2015) Discussion > What went wrong with this movie ?? or Sh...

What went wrong with this movie ?? or Shankar ...


(please pardon my bad english)

First of all let me say , iam a huge fan of SHANKAR , my favs. r Hindustani ,Nayak , Aparichit and Robot .
I simply hate south indian style films , (except shankar's and mani ratnam . they are exceptions in my eyes and i believe they have dlvrd d best commercial indian films . )
Bollywood are remaking south indian films n all , but i hate them too . they have no logic or what so ever .
yes movies are flawed and stuff but "I" was BAD on so many levels , it was surely a visual treat in some portions , but one can not ignore the rest of the things .
Ill name some few things which were totally unacceptable as a shankar's fan .

According to me the story was very bad and was told in a stupid way . Shankar made a regular *beep* south indian masala movie , with d topping of good visual . (set max ki yaaad agai :P ).

REALISM HIGHLY MISSING . Robot was much realistic than this . Infact i cant even compare coz robot got amazing amazing action sequences ,which made me so proud .
BUT IN THIS OHHHHH GOOOOOD .....
Does body builder means a man having all sort of super powers ? i mean look at those never ending action sequences , how people are flying and don't get hurt even with iron rods .

Leave that .....
Look at a Major Spoiler
Vikram get to know about the marriage just a day before , as the doctor clearly stated they were having a bachelor party n tomorrow he is getting married .
and vikram just planned every damn thing in a day and also did it in given time , i mean wow , even james bond couldn't pull that off (with all the helps he takes from his frens n beuro ) :P .
and thr r many more plot holes like this in the film .

leave artistic flaws , ON HUMANITY LEVEL also it sucked ...
Making jokes on women parts , quoting - apke HEADLIGHTS dekh ke iska fuse udd gaya , aap kapde pehen lo n kapde pehen ke isse baat kero .

Making fun of shemale was really pathetic and then justifying that fun by making shemale a stereotypical one and thn turning her into a villain . wow .

How can one even emotionally get connected to the main character when he himself was obsessed with only LOOKS . He dint knew amy jackson , falling in love before knowing her , making fun of a shemale but started giving a little respect when he get to know she takes 50000 for a day , worst thing letting his parents suffer by faking his own death coz his looks/body totally got ruin ? . i mean wow . that we call a hero ??

i started questioning shankar's moral now . totally disappointed .

reply