MovieChat Forums > Tai ji 2: Ying xiong jue qi (2012) Discussion > Slightly isolationist anti-west...

Slightly isolationist anti-west...


I know the empires caused issues, but movies from China and Korea seem to have a habit of the western evil like the cliché eastern terrorist or minority thug. Xui Xui got banned for showing corruption, so perhaps they have to avoid fully pointing the finger at internal issues, and they did waver on the line of the western company being more concerned with the profit than being "evil", and that town was a bunch of b@st@rds for not helping outsiders... Not sure where I am going with this, but the movie "Welcome to Dongmakol" always bugged me a little with the way the west was a bit to blame for things...it is like the thug getting off for the murder someone else paid him for, he was still a murderer.

reply

You're right. Those villagers were pretty fickle, and I didn't like the way they were so disloyal to Yang LuChan. However, anyone who knows even a modicum of history could understand why the Chinese would be just a tad xenophobic.

The short version is that they allowed outsiders to use their invention (gunpowder) as a means to enslave their country centuries later. A simple Google search of the Opium Wars and the "Century of Humiliation" would show that the Chinese were subjected to the forced acceptance of heroin, unfair trade laws, etc and only regained their independence as a result of WWII (as did India). Nonetheless, the long term effects are still ongoing. Despite extreme measures during the Mao Revolution to curb drug use, it is still a major epidemic in China even to the present day.

Knowing the history, wouldn't you be a bit distrustful (maybe even resentful) of outsiders, too?

-EdH

reply

I am not saying there should have been an anti-outsider, but it is white washing when you ignore all of the insider corruption. It is like trying to cure your cancer by blaming the cigarette companies...they are horrible, but until you actually remove you cancer nothing will happen. I am extremely environmental, but movies like Avatar just bugged me with the bad outsider causing the problems, this touched that same nerve. The bad guy needs to be developed, and not just a bad guy. This was like Shaolin Soccer with its bad guys, but Shaolin was done that way because it is so absurd to have a "Team Evil"...or a "Dr. Evil".

reply