MovieChat Forums > Witches of East End (2013) Discussion > Freya can recognize souls... *spoilers*

Freya can recognize souls... *spoilers*


Dash switched souls with Killian. Wouldn't Freya be able to see that? They made a huge deal about how Edgar Allan Poe looked just like Killian, but only to Freya. If Dash's soul is in Killian's body, I feel like she'd notice right away. I guess if it hadn't been cancelled I'd probably get my answer to this in the next season, but now I'm just left to speculate as to why she couldn't see the difference.

Also, apologies if this has been discussed before, but I'm on mobile, and it's harder to navigate the boards on there than on the computer.

Everybody lives, Rose! Just this once, everybody lives!

reply

You make such a good point! Nooooo one else notices the similarities of Killian and Poe but Dash just sneaks in there?

Maybe it's just been on trauma too many that night. Otherwise what a gaping plot hole.

~'~Vibrational Match!~'~

reply

Her dad recognized Gillian from another life too, but maybe she gets that from his side of the family?

I agree that the only reason she didn't recognize him right away was because she was overwhelmed by everything that had just happened.

reply

Dash has a line of dialogue about the soul switch being undetectable. Renders the Freya-Killian love connection thing sort of pointless but whatever. Plot device

reply

You're so right! I thought about that right away as well

reply

Well In triple moon the short story conclusion to the cliff hangers, Freya finds out rather quickly that they switched souls. She finds out what spell Dash used, etc. in fact, the way the show ended and the way the story was written, it happened almost the next day. But you have to read it for it to make sense. FYI they use the time door.

reply