MovieChat Forums > Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle (2017) Discussion > I find it hard to believe....(SPOILERS)

I find it hard to believe....(SPOILERS)


that the Jumanji we're shown in this film is the place where Robin Williams' character Alan Parrish got sucked in when he was a child. In the original classic Alan Parrish described the jungle by saying "I've seen things you've only seen in your nightmares. Things you can't even imagine. Things you can't even see. There are things that hunt you in the night. Then something screams. Then you hear them eating, and you hope to God that you're not dessert. Afraid? You don't even know what afraid is." Based on this description as an audience we could tell that the world of Jumanji is a dark scary place. In this new film it doesn't seem like the place Alan Parrish described.

Another reason why I find it hard to believe that Alan Parrish was trapped in the jungle shown in this new Jumanji film is because in the original Jumanji film, when Alan finally escapes the game after 26 years, he emerges in leaves and pieces of cloth, briefly mentioning that he's had no amenities during his time in the Jungle, yet there's a bazaar in Jumanji where people clearly wear normal clothes, and Alan's treehouse that he had constructed clearly has working power (Seaplane is able to use a blender while there). So that was really confusing.

Also some things from the original were missing such as the lion, the monkeys, the bats, quicksand, giant spiders, the growing vines and the stampede (yes we're shown rhinos running but where were the zebras and elephants in the stampede) So yeah this Jumanji world we're shown in the film doesn't seem like the place Alan Parrish described. What do you guys think?

reply

Yes to this!
As luck would have it, I recently re-watched the original with my 8-year-old nephew. I have fond memories of watching it way back when with my now grown sons.

The movie still holds up despite the clunky CGI because of the story. And, yes, based on Alan Parrish' description, I always pictured Jumanji as some sort of nightmarish Neverland, filled with monstrous creatures that we would recognize, but with bigger fangs and claws. Van Pelt was the Captain Hook of this alternative universe. His style of dress and his elephant gun hinted at a place where technology was primitive at best.

So it was jarring to me to see helicopters and motorcycles in the previews for the new movie and I just can't connect it to the Jumanji of the original. It looks more like they put together a fantasy movie with a similar setup, and then stuck Jumanji in the title to appeal to nostalgic Millennials.

reply

I agree too that it doesn’t seem like the same place as the first movie.

reply

I think the jungle updated when the game did.

reply

The original Jungle is definitely implied to be a sort of Lost World/Savage World type place, where sabertooth tigers are still around, maybe morlocks and dinosaurs.

reply

Agreed. Even basic lore that the first film introduced, like however much time passes in the 'real world' will pass in the jungle, wasn't used in this film. Otherwise, why didn't you-know-who age?

However, I do think that has something to do with board game-video game conversion. And it didn't halt my enjoyment of this version, so it wasn't a huge problem.

reply

I agree, but it seems obvious to me that the game changed as it became a rendition of a computer gane setting. It had many typical computer games elements in it, and those Could not have been in the world Alan inhabited. The game then was a kin to board games and so mostly driven by unpredictable and unlimited fantasy. Computer games are fantasy too, but inherently ruled by rules. And this we see. I say the games adjust or evolves.

That being said, as a computer game it did not seem so hard to play. Dwayn Johnson was unbeatable (was he not scare) so with that avatar I think I could finish the game in a jif... In Alan”s time it seemed near unbearable. So should have made it much more challenging.... something like all the characters dying one by one and to only return if it is finished in the end by one of them. If they would have designed it like this instead of everyone needs to survive to finish .. the games difficulty could had been set to hard and more en pas with how Alan described it.

reply

While agreeing, I'd say the new movie was about console games. The movie felt like playing Uncharted, with all the usual scripting and power-character-fantasy elements. Had the movie been like Dark Souls, for example, that would have been quite another story.

reply

Good explanation

reply

I agreed. the Jumanji jungle that was shown in this movie looks nothing like the place Alan Parrish described.

reply

In my time as a forest ranger, I've seen bears do things that sometimes even a bear wouldn't do!

reply

A bear can't do all things all the time and thus does things it sometimes won't do.

reply