MovieChat Forums > Satyagraha (2013) Discussion > rajanahuja4: reply to reviews.

rajanahuja4: reply to reviews.

posted 11 years ago by AwaixJvd
3 replies | jump to latest

I am writing this for some people who are thinking that film was deviated after the mid of it.Yes i agree,even after intermission it lost the charm,and director could end it in better way rather than showing such abrupt changes.
but

this is the story of a common man,who stood for change.he doesn't know the politics and rise and fall of politics game.he is unaware of the fact that what he must do at right moment,he is just for the good cause and change.obviously he is not a born politician who knows how to manipulate the situations and take 360 turns in the next moment.

this is the reply for all the reviews in this forum,and reviews threads,and specially to:
rajanahuja4 review

[–] AmberDi 11 years ago

The film drifted a lot - and the screenplay was just not good enough, considering how good Rajneeti was.

There were several lapses:

eg.

1. Why did Amitji suddenly embrace Ajay after coming out of prison?
2. The relationship between ajay and amitji's son needed to be explained better, to show how he helped him as a orphan, which would give a meaning to why Ajay was so affected by the loss, that he tossed his own dreams and life away to help Amitji.
3. Arjun Rampal was totally wasted in this film. He should have had a much larger role.
4. The villification of Ajay - again this seemed rushed and not well thought out.

I guess we had higher expectations of Prakash Jah after Rajneeti which is why this was a let down.

[–] AwaixJvd 11 years ago

yes indeed,Arjun Rampal was always considered a low potential person when industry focuses on a rubbish SRK,who was no doubt good in 90s but his time is over,his kind of acting is not considered good anymore.Time is changing.

Arjun Rampal was a solid character in Raajneeti, Om shanti om, and my favorite one of his recent films, inkaar. He indeed has a great talent when it comes to serious acting but it also depends on the director who should know who is what and what is who,what are the potentials of his cast and who is the strongest one according to roles.

Indian and Pakistani cinema are both at very mature stages,even the Hollywood is same.They produce good films,but don't know who can perform what.See Persian cinema,French cinema,Turkish cinema and you will find the real life topics comes from them.They know how to make someone act and give a full of life acting.

[–] zohaib_malik 10 years ago

This movie is a charba movie of Pakistani film Chambeli.