MovieChat Forums > The Mill (2013) Discussion > Makes me wonder how the Greg family desc...

Makes me wonder how the Greg family descendents feel about this series


They are not particularly harshly shown, as whatever autocratic behaviors they show in the series were simply of that time and place and cannot be judged by today's standards.

The Greg family are almost portrayed as banal in their harsh attitudes. The writer tries to defend their business practices by having Robert Greg explain several times why he has so much pressure on him to turn a profit in the difficult business circumstances of that time--and with Parliament breathing down his neck with new legislation on the horizon.

But the writer rather backed off of that pretty quickly, and did not try TOO hard to make his business position sympathetic, as with modern sensibilities of viewers and a union-centric work world viewership might not continue to tune in if too much of a defense is made of his reasons for the way he runs the mill.

By that day's standards, they are actually being portrayed pretty sympathetically, considering what went on in some other mills of the time.

I wonder if John F. had any access to today's Greg family members or their family records, that are outside the purview of the National Trust, which is in possession of the house and mill now?

Not sure how I'd feel if this were my family being shown.

reply

While I understand where you are coming from, I think the harsh truth of it is that no one woud be happy fully with what their family did in past eras, because it was a different time with different values and different views on many things including work, illness, drink, women, etc so I can't really see many people who would have all glowing family trees by todays values and standards.

I believe the series did give the Gregs a sympathetic stand point on some aspects, but I think it also showed they were still running a business and still rich with a snobby attitude to lower classes, which I think would have been on the nose for the most part. It also showed that they helped the workers better themselves and gave them better working conditions, perhaps this would have been more clear if they'd shown a little more of what life was like in other mills around this time to give a stark contrast.

I think the series was more focused upon the plight of the workers rather than the Gregs so perhaps it was a little biased and did not give fair light onto the Gregs good intentions, but then I feel they'd need more episodes to develop the characters of Sam and Robert and show their stand point and focus on Sam's 'ideal', which was paved with good intentions. But still, by today's standards the mill jobs at Quarry were hard, back breaking, work with little money, food and prospects for the future unless you were lucky enough to stay on and get a steady job, not to mention no retirement money, no money for getting sick from cotton dust, cancer etc....
So I think the series showed a fair light on the conditions of mill life and the business mindset.

But from what I've read at Quarry and been told by the staff, living only 10 mins away from Quarry and visiting it more times than I can remember, the Greg's descendents are very proud of their history and family... and I think so they should be really, they helped pave the way for reform and the work ethics we have today.


"Never bite into an apple without knowing what lies within..."

reply

They do make nice sausage rolls though...

reply