MovieChat Forums > The Bag Man (2014) Discussion > Why are people bagging on this movie? Wh...

Why are people bagging on this movie? What a strange little noir!


I absolutely loved the off-kilter atmosphere, the dream-like way people were acting and speaking, it wasn't Lynch-level trippy, but I must say this is one of the better modern neo-noirs I've seen along with Killer Joe.

Go watch 9 Souls on Veehd and thank me later. It is truly an existential masterpiece...

reply

[deleted]

It’s a De Niro/Cusack movie and people think that because it was released day and date then that means it’s crap. So they jump on that bandwagon. Not a lot of thinking for themselves. It’s a tough genre to get a wide release. Perhaps if it had a famous director then it could have got one. It’s a fun, dream like noir. Unusual story. Tense at times but invariably with a witty remark to then relieve the tension.

reply

I agree with you. The movie was fairly good and entertaining. A sure sign that a demographic of the movie audience has lumpen proletariat tastes is when you read or hear the words "boring" or "too slow," from them. The average movie now (out of hollywood) contains triple the amount of cuts and edits than a film did 10 years ago. Anything that doesn't have some sort of action or violence every 15 minutes will be called "boring" by an unfortunately large American demographic. And the internet, social and contemporary new media has re-wired the brain.

reply

Same here - I liked it!

reply

It’s terrific. Overtime it will become recognized.

reply

Yeah, I realy don't understand why this movie is getting bashed. Just saw it, like it a lot. Interesting story, good acting, convincing characters and a lot of dark athosphere. In my opinion not realy a neo-noir but close enough. I rated it a 7.

reply

yes. i thought the cheesy "don't look in the bag, no matter what" routine would be best we'd get, but it wasn't! a filmmaker's film, for sure.

reply

Very under-rated. Neo-noir classic. Must see!

reply

You ****ing guys getting paid or something?

This movie was trash, i like the actors nothing against them but i'd rather shovel *beep* all day then watch this piece of *beep* again.

reply

This is very underrated. Top class movie.

reply

Acting was good, but the story and writing lacked depth. The plot twists were ill conceived and predictable. They way they got in and out of jams was pedestrian. Compare this movie to No Country for Old Men and see what I mean. Also, the contents of the bag was tipped off when Cusack disclosed that his wife was dead. The first thing I thought was "Hmmm, his dead wife's head. Just like Se7en".

"Loves turned to lust and bloods turned to dust in my heart"

reply