concerning the rating


The movie is just awesome and one of the best romantic movie ever made. So this movie desrves to be rated above 9 because the acting is awesome as well as the direction is incredible

reply

i totally agree with u.
best luv story ever 2 come out of bollywood

reply

Don't you think the story was cliched? Just because it has a sad ending doesn't mean that it can be dubbed as the best...

Performances were great; although Shraddha Kapoor still needs to work harder with her diction.

Unorthodox Cinema Critic Since 2009.

reply

Lol.. You surely need to update your movie list. One of the best romantic movies ever made? Haha.. 7.6 is itself on the higher side. It is somewhere around 6.5-7 at max. The acting is decent. But too many cliches.

___
www.randomizedsnippets.wordpress.com
Follow me at http://twitter.com/Wolverin3

reply

Very true....movie ought to get a rating of below 6....This was a unique movie where direction was pathetic but it was the fabulous acting by both the leading actors that makes it an intriguing watch....it was like actors trying to nullify director's faults every now & then.....

Aashiqui 2 ought to be watched for its actors, surely not for pitiful direction or storytelling....this script has been used many a times in the past (very much close to Dil Vil Pyar Vyar), only with a different ending.

reply

really!!! i guess i have better updated movie list. Movie doesn't mean to be good by big names. even a new comer may also get out a beautiful movie. Go for 3 Idiots its also a nice example for you.

reply

It was a ok kinda movie & 7.6 is way too much... the ending was made this way just to get sympathy of audience ... the direction was totally lost

reply

Best Movie to9 come out of bollywood?? what are you smoking??, it was mildly engaging at best. Great music & decent time pass. 6/10

reply

First of all. I don't think this deserves a point better rating than it already have. The main reason for that is the acting of the 2 main characters. Aditya Roy Kapoor was pathetic in many scenes. He never looked like an Alcoholic Rockstar in the movie. Most of his emotions looked mechanical. And Shraddha initially failed to act in some initial scenes though she was better among the two. In the second half of the film though, two of them picked up their act better.
For me, Mohit Suri did a fine job. He never let us felt the immature acting of the 2 actors shown on screen to an extend. If you want to know how an alcoholic can be portrayed, I suggest you watch films like Yavanika [1982] or Spirit [2012]. After watching Aashiqui 2 I really fell in love with another film, Rockstar [2011]. Aditya Roy Kapoor was no where near the performance of Ranbir Kapoor in that film, though the characters they portrayed were of similar shades. May be I am too harsh on 2 actors that are pretty newcomers. But still for me, they somewhat were a thorn in an otherwise delicious meal.

reply

I agree. I enjoyed the movie, but at times I felt that Aditya Roy was incapable of delivering what exactly his role desired. His spot expressions irritated me many times. I don't complain much on Shraddha's acting as her role was not supposed to engage the viewer to the storyline until the later part of the movie (in which she did that successfully). Aditya had a very difficult role, which could have created the movie a true blockbuster (like Sharabi of Amitabh, or Devdas of Dilip Kumar), if he could have acted better. Story was good, and direction was better than expected. It was the music that truly attached me to the movie (the music was the main reason for watching this movie, as I wouldn't have watched the movie otherwise.)

reply

Whoa Above 9 , it can't be more than 6.About 6 is decent rating for movie.

reply

You made me cringe with shame. In my 22 years of existence on this planet, this has never happened to me. And I have to add that I'm very tolerant with things I come across.

<The movie is just awesome>
No, it's not. The plot of the movie was foolishly mundane and artificial. No explanations were provided for his drinking problem, and the solutions he had employed were unrealistic. The entry of the female lead was most opportune and the way she invaded his life was totally uncalled for. Nobody does that in this world.

<one of the best romantic movie ever made>
Seriously, man? Are you freaking kidding me? Haven't you watched movies at all? Was the the first you've seen since you've been born on Earth? Even Twilight is better than this story, considering the negative flack the movie has got!
Haven't you ever watched the classics, or the modern? Goodness, I could go on about this!

<deserves to be rated above 9>
You cannot ever judge that, please. You might have rated it a 10, I'd never rate it above 5. The movie was as pathetic as Sonia Gandhi smiling benevolently. Everybody knows she's faking it, pathetically.

<acting is awesome>
Both of the actors were amateurs. I couldn't decide which one I hated more. The guy acted like *beep* had dialogues like *beep* and enacted them like *beep* The girl seemed like she was competing with him in the same terms.

<direction is incredible>
Do you even recognize the change in direction when you see it? By this point, I don't even have to comment anything more. You know what MY point is.

reply

Really, A Star is Born? Barbra Streisand? A Star is Born? Judy Garland? knoc, knoc, India.

reply

Better voices of reason aren't heard in this movies boards. WTF is anybody thinking this movies deserves ratings like 9.

I felt like destroying something beautiful.

reply

hahaha.. I agree with u n differ with original post.. No way 9.. may be the 9 is on a scale of 15 :P.. if this is 9/10 then more than 40% of the Bollywood movies are 10 on 10.. hahaha

reply

i don't think it can be 9 but an 8 is ok

reply

lol TLDR..calm down, don't get so upset

reply

i like this move. though the ending was a shocked one, it is different, some thing to be worried even after the film.
happy it is not a typical hindi movie.

reply

I am a little concerned about people's choice. I mean what is so great in this movie that it deserves so many accolades. Except for music and songs the movie sucks with both ARK and SK sucking in acting. I mean if someone does not realise the implications of his bad habits (drinking) on his career, his frnds and formost his love then he does not deserve to own it all.. And after so many people telling he does not realise it. And come on what if u r not able to sing after u hav messed up urself. U could try hard start from scratch. This is like showing how he had taken his life for granted. My opinion is well u cud take ur life for granted and do whatever but u hav no right to mess up others life, when u know u cant avoid it..

I give it 4/10

reply