MovieChat Forums > The Counselor (2013) Discussion > READ: Guillermo Del Toro loves "The Coun...

READ: Guillermo Del Toro loves "The Counselor"


It took a Mexican artist to understand this film's significance…and he's spot on:


INTERVIEW by Mike Fleming Jr
October 16, 2015



(…)
DEADLINE: Ridley Scott recently told Deadline that despite its failure to find an audience, he dearly loves his Cormac McCarthy-scripted film The Counselor. You’ve told me that aside from immersing yourself in your genre world, you watch certain movies over and over for inspiration. Why is The Counselor one of them?

DEL TORO: Here’s what I love. Cormac McCarthy’s writing is so true to itself. It doesn’t want to comply with the screenplay manuals and it doesn’t try to conform to the conventional breaks of the three-act structure. Nevertheless, the movie has a really nightmarishly escalating structure. It is beautifully structured and I can tell you, as somebody who first hand has suffered the devastating consequences of violence more than once, the movie captures three of the fundamental stages of a human’s life. You meet the counselor at the moment where he is at his most shielded and placid, when he is buying the diamond and is all but oblivious to the transcendentally destructive power of violence. He very glibly dabbles into that on the second stage, where he’s very ambitious and all about a future life with a new bride and newly acquired wealth. All through that journey, the counselor meets these guides into the underworld who warn him. Beware, here there be dragons, and the counselor ignores all those signals and signposts. Then the movie tells you, once you cross this line, the world as you know it disappears. For anyone that has not experienced violence, this may seem like an intellectual or literary conceit. I know, from a very painful place, what it is to lose people you love.

DEADLINE: You’ve said that while you lived in Mexico your father was kidnapped and held for months before you paid a ransom to bring him back. Is that what you mean?

DEL TORO: I am talking about both in the past with my father, and more recently I have experienced people being taken and disappearing. I can tell you the movie articulates the cosmic power of violence to destroy one’s concept of the universe in a way that nobody else has and nobody else will. It is not post-modern fascination with violence where we want to play gangster by being tough. This is a movie that tells you violence is the destroyer of worlds. It will scorch your earth and you will be banned and it has an almost Old Testament power that is unique. And, very sadly, it is out of touch with what audiences want.

DEADLINE: For all its star power, the movie failed to capture an audience…

DEL TORO: But we need to not be confused in these times by equating popularity with quality. And when a movie comes in that is as well-thought and as contemplative as this one, we owe it to ourselves to honor that creation with the time and attention it demands and not watch it like one would an in-flight entertainment movie or a Sunday outing. It’s a true, powerful meditation on violence.

DEADLINE: I find myself vexed that Robert Zemeckis’ The Walk hasn’t caught on. When I saw it in 3D Imax, it left me sweating and feeling I’d never seen that on a movie screen before. The way Zemeckis put you on that wire, 110 stories up between those Twin Towers…

DEL TORO: I think there is a certainty you have as a filmmaker, that when you raise your child to be itself, as we were discussing, the child will grow even after you’re gone. There are movies like The Walk or The Counselor that one makes with the hope of finding an audience like a message in a bottle will find the shore and be read in the right way, with the right amount of pure love. With most Zemeckis movies in the last couple of decades — including Flight which I find enormously rewarding — I see a master, talking to me and talking to everyone that wants to hear. We have a history of not always listening to those that are right. We’ve even crucified them. I don’t think that people with something to say are necessarily the same people that are heard. Zemeckis is one of the most singular talents working in film. A monumental talent that we take for granted in a way that we shouldn’t.

DEADLINE: What other movies have obsessed you?

DEL TORO: I have a handful I watch over and over. The Big Lebowski is one. Catch Me if You Can. Duel. Every day, I watch one or two movies and those are almost like symphonic music or favorite songs. The one that accidentally entered that realm lately is No Country for Old Men because I was reviewing it to interview the Coens. And all of a sudden that one started to echo a lot the way The Counselor and some of the ideas of the world. I started to watch them back to back. Road Warrior is another.

DEADLINE: You mean George Miller’s Mad Max: Fury Road, which came out this summer and was another film that didn’t do as well as deserved, given its ballsy, audacious vision?

DEL TORO: I meant the original, because it was so important when it came out. Now, Fury Road is an amazing feat, just an amazing spectacle. It’s choreographed and orchestrated in a way that is like a caravan, a moving three-ring circus of action. It’s almost Cirque du Soleil, the most acrobatic action film ever made. What I love most of all is the fable of a filmmaker who remains untamed. This guy is over 70 years old and, very much like Ridley Scott, he keeps responding to his own impulses. These are guys delivering some of their best work at an age where most people have retired. These are grand masters. I find the exuberance of George’ Miller’s work to be the same that comes out in an unexpected way in The Wolf Of Wall Street with Marty Scorsese. You would believe these movies were made by a new director who is 22 years old.

DEADLINE: Quentin Tarantino has said he’ll retire soon, before he begins repeating himself and his next movie cannot be his best one. Are you saying the accumulation of craftsmanship skills and creative recklessness can keep you from that decline?

DEL TORO: I think so. What is very beautiful in my opinion is that you can get that second wind if you are given the chance to work with a certain continuity. These are people who are still working at the top of their game, in a language that was always their own. They don’t betray that. I for one actually hope and expect that Quentin changes his mind.

http://deadline.com/2015/10/crimson-peak-guillermo-del-toro-donald-trump-mexican-immigrants-1201585629/#comment-list-wrapper

reply

Wow thanks for posting. I'm glad to see that I'm really not alone in really appreciating this film and at least one other acclaimed filmmaker loves it. I agree particularly with what he said about McCarthy's writing style. It's one that's all his own, and doesn't follow the conventions, but that's what makes it so great and interesting. For people that say it didn't flow right and things didn't make sense, it did, they're just missing a lot of it cos they're used to a certain style and waiting for predictable things to happen. This is the story McCarthy had in his mind, so there's no point wishing it was something else. Just watch and listen to the story. And it really did play out like a nightmare, where one thing led to another and you just know it won't let up, because that's how nightmares are. Also very atmospheric. I also liked how he said you have to watch this like you're watching art, and actually give it some thought and attention. It's not a movie you just throw on and only give it one chance to entertain you the way you expect it to.

reply

I agree.

I don't think this movie is even ment to entertain.

It's ment to shock, frustrate and depress.

It's anti-entertainment produced with all the elements we see in lavish genre entertainments.

That's what makes it unique.

It's a medieval morality play.

reply

I'm glad to see that I'm really not alone in really appreciating this film and at least one other acclaimed filmmaker loves it.


So you're an acclaimed filmmaker. Would you care to identify yourself?


reply

Where in that post did I say I was one? I was just glad there's an acclaimed filmmaker out there who realises that it's actually a great movie, which means something to me cos you would expect an acclaimed filmmaker to know what they're talking about. By "one other" acclaimed filmmaker I meant someone other than Ridley Scott, the acclaimed filmmaker who made it

reply

I don't use emojis, so please know that I was just having a bit of fun.

reply

Oh. No worries :)

reply

Great interview!

I, too, have been obsessively rewatching The Counselor ever since it came out. The film community has not yet come to grips with what a masterpiece it was...

reply

I've seen it many times but it was on TV in Australia last night and I watched it again, and it really never ceases to amaze. Even though you know what's coming, it still has that atmosphere of escalating dread throughout, and I always feel so much anxiety for the characters. People may ask why that's a good thing, and all I can say it when a film manages to achieve that, it means it is masterwork, so I appreciate it greatly from an artistic standpoint. It's a shame people don't appreciate what real art is. All they want is entertainment and movies that give them joy.

reply

[deleted]

I can tell you the movie articulates the cosmic power of violence to destroy one’s concept of the universe in a way that nobody else has and nobody else will. It is not post-modern fascination with violence where we want to play gangster by being tough. This is a movie that tells you violence is the destroyer of worlds. It will scorch your earth and you will be banned and it has an almost Old Testament power that is unique. And, very sadly, it is out of touch with what audiences want.


While the whole piece is an insightful read, this part in particular is strikingly poignant on Del Toro's part. This, I think, is part of why audiences at large weren't ready for this film: because it actually has the audacity to take violence and its implications seriously. Scott/McCarthy's film does not have any juvenile Frank Miller/Quentin Tarantino ironic distance towards the suffering of the world, and so it's more than a bit out of sync with cultural demands.

That son of a bitch! Don't get me wrong, he's a fine writer.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Del Toro has summed it up perfectly. For me, the guys warning him reminded me of Faust.

reply

For me, the guys warning him reminded me of Faust.

That's true.

There's something of the "Faust" legend in this...

reply

[deleted]

Fantastic read. Del Toro is a very intelligent filmmaker, he understands. The counselor is truly a fantastic piece of art, but people were just not ready for a film that is so different from Hollywood mainstream. It´s just not a rewarding movie and that´s why many who were expecting a standard Thriller with a great cast, had a hard time with it.

reply