MovieChat Forums > Rewind (2013) Discussion > They lost me at the 'panopticon'

They lost me at the 'panopticon'


If they have a computer that can do that, why not one that can analyze the images seen through the time window to determine the date, one that can rapidly manufacture accurate period costumes, etc., etc.

reply

The panoptican predicated what a city in the present would like based upon a change in the past. It doesn't do anything else but analyze what is changed based upon a theoretical change in the past. And it does this because it is hooked up to a bunch of supercomputers with lots of data.

Christians call it faith ... I call it the herd.
-- Friedrieh Wilhelm Nietzsche

reply

Yeah, it sounded good but in practice still way beyond what we can do. Imagine trying to accurately predict the weather on your birthday 100 years from now when the truth is that today we're lucky if we get it right beyond 3 days. With our current techniques it's not even possible even if we could turn the entire universe into one massive computer (and some say that's exactly what the universe is).

Also, the costumes came from the Smithsonian, which does indeed have huge collections of period items from the history of the US. I don't know what they would have done if they had to go outside the US or before the Smithsonian was up and running.

reply

Well they did have an expert and well there are ways to make clothing, items that would be passable. I suspect if it had gotten picked up they would have shown that they had acquired equipment to quickly make period outfits in a short amount of time.

Also well here is the thing they have done some tests on a supercomputer named Nautilus and it was able to accurately predict things like riots, crimes, just based upon news stories, publicly accessible data etc. Mind you this was them asking the computer program after years or months after the events had taken place but the computer was able to predict these things while humans weren't able to do so.

So yeah that future predication tech is based upon real world experiments going on right now.

Christians call it faith ... I call it the herd.
-- Friedrieh Wilhelm Nietzsche

reply

I know they need some device like this for the show to work, but the name is pathetic. They might as well have called it the "flux projector" or a "Wonderflonium forecaster"



I was born in the house my father built

reply

Yes, that was easily the weakest plot point. A very convenient (and fast!) way to get the whole 'time can be changed' notion across.

The "spectaculocaster" pinpoints trivial events a hundred years ago and accurately calculates how it would change all of Earth's history... in 7 seconds or less! lolz!

reply

They lost me when they decided that the most important mission in human evolution required everyone to stop and drink beers including the security guards!

reply

But smoking wasn't allowed.

reply

The Panopticon was a ridiculous idea, but even if they had something that gave general ideas of what might happen based on what they knew from the future of the past, they could not possibly know or predict what a given landscape or local neighborhood would look like from that. That was just plain stupid.

reply

It's just a movie.

Enrique Sanchez

reply

a stupid movie.

reply

Sorry for your empty life.

Enrique Sanchez

reply

I think it should have been called a decepticon OR since that name was actually used and i dont know if they would have gotten permission to call it that, they could call it a Supercalifragilisticexpialidociousopticon


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_BbtXj2P4g

reply