MovieChat Forums > Proxy (2014) Discussion > So many questions!

So many questions!


So many questions!

Why did Esther make a pass at Melanie when she already has a girlfriend?

What was the reasoning behind Anika killing off Esther's baby?

Why did Melanie think Payton was missing when she went shopping?

Add your own . . . .

reply

Well for starters Esther was crazy.

Melanie knew Peyton wasn't missing. She walked slowly and calmly back to the car where she knew he was. She was doing it for attention. Just like she lied at the support groups. Didn't you notice her fantasies of being on TV and when she was watching recordings of the news?

reply

Esther had her girlfriend attack her and kill the baby because as Esther said, she loved being pregnant but never wanted to be a mother.
A similar attention-seeking sickness as Melanie.

reply

Why not give birth to the baby and let someone adopt him? Man this was so unnecessary of her. Brutal scene for sure.

reply

Adoption doesn't get nearly as much attention as a brutal attack where you loose the baby you supposedly loved and wanted and we're looking forward to/planning for.
ALL about the attention!!

reply