Diablo / Civilization
Ok, I've played Diablo and Civi since they were both brand new. With Civ, it was stellar until Civ V.
When Civ V came out the critics went wild, and anyone who's played Civ for a long time thought it was a giant smelly turd.
So now I don't trust game critics anymore. Can ANYONE who was burned by Civ V please give me their opinion of Diablo #3?