House exterior looked like Amityvelle horror house

Exactly what I thought. You don't see windows like that often.

Glad someone else thought the same thing I did

That style is pretty common in the northeast, I have seen a lot of them in in older neighborhoods in Connecticut, as well as Long Island's north Shore and the South Shore near the Amityville area

Colonials in the Northeast aren't all that rare.

Life is pain. Anyone who says differently is selling something.

Dutch Colonial. My favorite style. NY was originally settled by many Dutch people (It was originally called New Amsterdam) so it is somewhat common here. Luckily not overly so.