I prefer Pinge + Purge (but not bad)
I don't think this was bad but for me the best Metallica concert video is Live Sh#t: Pinge & Purge. The band sounded more rocking than ever. James had a good voice and scream. Also they play a lot of "... And Justice for All" -songs that I love. I actually wrote a blog about the album if anyone is interested to read it.
http://jesselanemaze.blogspot.com