How is this a comedy?


The back of the DVD features a blurb from John Waters calling it "Hilariously funny!" That's why I decided to watch it the other night. I was in the mood for some laughs. It's also listed as a comedy on here. But I don't understand why. I don't mean that sarcastically, in that it's not a comedy but shouldn't be called so because it isn't funny, e.g. Napoleon Dynamite. I mean, there don't seem to be any attempts at humor in the film. It's just a dark, weird movie that came off as straight and serious. I didn't sense any irony.

reply

Firstly, this is a quote from John Waters and he's not the kind of man whose taste is completely in line with that of the general public.

Secondly, while I agree that "Hilariously funny" would be a bit much, I think the dark comedy label fits the film well. A lot of the humour is supposed to come from the characters being vapid or obnoxious or cruel or unintentionally absurd. There are a fair few moments and lines that can be singled out as comedic, especially in the first two acts.

***

Jerome on Scientology: "I was thinking about converting, just as a career move."

Cammy: "I like Bad Babysitter. You were so funny."
Benjie: "Yeah... we did 780 million worldwide. People don't realize that."
[Awkward silence]

Benjie: "So, how'd you get aids, Cammy?"
Cammy: "Um, I don't have aids. It's non-Hodgkin lymphoma."
[Benjie blinks a few times and turns to give his agent an 'Are you kidding?' look.]

Benjie: "What the fvck's non-Hodgkins?"
Arnold: "I think it's a blood thing."
Benjie: "I mean, non. It either is or it isn't."

Benjie's agent comments on the idea to have Ryan Gosling play Benjie in a film where Benjie plays Cammy, the female sufferer of non-Hodgkin lymphoma: "We can definitely get this to Ryan. It's just the kind of stuff he likes to do."

Dr. Stafford Weiss: "I'm gonna press on a personal history point. Everything's stored in the thighs."

Genie: "So did you call the police?"
Havana: "Yeah, I told her I would if she didn't go to rehab."
Genie: "I see, so she's there now, huh?"
Havana: "Yeah, with all the other dope fiend personal assistants. They have their own wing."

Two of Benjie’s vapid female co-stars, Sam and Kayla, discuss the age of 23-year old actress Deandra: “She’s got a tramp stamp, okay? She’s… menopausal!”
[They laugh heartily.]
Fifteen seconds later, they’re discussing Rhett not going down on Kayla during her period: “Well, he can’t… because you’re menopausal!”
[They laugh heartily. Again.]
Another fifteen seconds later, they’re discussing the age of Havana Segrand: “Totally menopausal.”

Sam wonders whether Sterl Carruth is sleeping with Havana Segrand.
Kayla: “Eh, she’d be like a mercy fvck.”
Sam: “Like when orderlies rape old people in nursing homes.”

Sterl Carruth’s response when Havana says she just might not be comfortable with lesbian sex: “Why don’t you take a Klonopin.”

Dr. Stafford Weiss to Hevana: “You’re welcoming mom into the house. You’re saying, ‘Hey mom, come on in. You don’t scare me. I’m empowered. Soup’s on!’”

Benjie after working with young Roy: “I need something to eat. My blood sugar drops every time I do a scene with Mr. ‘Piece of S***’ Vabina.”

Benjie’s response when Jeb brings his two nieces to get Benjie’s autograph: “Universal Studios. Put their asses on the tram, Jebbo.” [Shuts the door.]

Agatha: “How did you find me?”
Dr. Stafford Weiss: “Please. No film noir questions.”

Havana: “I need you to go back to Wholefoods and get me a laxative. I think it’s called Quiet Moment.” [Farts] “They should call it Un-quiet Moment.”

Benjie: “Where’s Kayla?”
Rhett: “Oh… *beep* her.”
Benjie: “I did. After the teamsters sold her my poop. She got it for a song.”
Rhett: “You mean for a schlong?” [To his new GF, Gretchen] It’s a long story.”
Benjie: “Long and coiled.”

reply

No way this is a comedy.
A very disturbing movie.

reply

Not necessarily a comedy, but I definitely felt it had some humorous moments.

reply

Not a comedy. A disturbing drama, with some darkly comedic moments and actions

reply

Even if some scenes could be considered "weird" enough to be funny, the tone was not comedy at all.


I'm Winston Wolf. I solve problems.

...And no dream is ever... just a dream...

reply

Funnier than most "comedies" though! To me, at least.

reply

It's a satire of Hollywood and celebrity. It classifies as a comedy.

reply

This definitely isn't a comedy and shouldn't be listed as a comedy on here.

reply

The joke is on the viewer.

reply

Are you kidding? Julianne Moore taking a shit and farting while asking Agatha about her sex life, forcing the poor girl to hang around and see/smell the ordeal, and finishing by barely wiping herself before pulling up her panties and not washing her hands... was gut-bustingly funny!

reply