7.0?


9/10 for me. Here's hoping it will take the scar this Sunday.


"Flash, Flash, I love you, but we only have fourteen hours to save the Earth!"

reply

Yes, people prefer the mediocre "Paperman" (a film that STOLE a lot from another short film "Signs").

reply

Paperman IS better. Less is more. remember that. Adam and Dog didn't really have a story. just wonder shots.

reply

What "story" did "Paperman" have? "Signs" was actually better (a short film that "Paperman" stole from). No, "Paperman" WAS mediocre Oscar bait. Its "story" was cheesy and cliched (very superficial).

reply

Paperman is all about how hundreds of people pass each other on the streets everyday in big cities such as New York or Chicago and how briefly for a split second they make a connection with their eyes but lose it in an instant. And how one of those connections might be real if we followed it. that is the whole point. they met in the city for just a second but it was more than that. it was destiny that led them together. Adam and dog? dog playing around with human. thee end.

reply

Yes, "Paperman" is just another superficial and cliched love at first sight film... It stole from "Signs" and Fantastic Books. "Adam and Dog" is about how loyal and forgiving dogs are. Both films plots are very simplistic (they're more about visual storytelling). "Paperman" is no deeper than "Adam and Dog"...

reply

Well you have your opinion and i respect it but i disagree. Paperman was much more of a story than adam and dog. On terms of directing Paperman blows adam and dog out the water. Not only was it shorter and more cohesive but every second in the film was something exciting. In Adam and Dog it felt like Lee was trying to get his Malick on. it wasn't working at least for me. But we all have our opinions.

reply

"Paperman" is dull and mediocre. I didn't find ANYTHING exciting. Yes, "Adam and Dog" has style that recalls Malick, but I find it a lot fresher than "Paperman" (there wasn't anything original or interesting about it).

reply

Hey i respect your opinion. we all can't like the same thing.

reply

Beatiful Short I think it should be around 8/10



When there's no more room in hell, The dead will walk the earth...

reply

4/10
It has some beatiful wander shots and thats it, and it and once again the christian story is shown as something beatiful.

---------------------------------------------
Applied Science? All science is applied. Eventually.

reply