MovieChat Forums > Saving Mr. Banks (2013) Discussion > Disturbing Undertones in Australia Flash...

Disturbing Undertones in Australia Flashbacks


I saw the movie for a second time today. Love it but I was never keen on the Aussie flashbacks to begin with, they slow the movie right down.

But for some reason I felt that Colin Farrell's character and performance was deeply disturbing.

His relationship with Ginty is borderline incestuous. I felt like he was in love with her--

He hardly ever shows any interest in his wife.
He practically ignores his other daughter.
Almost everything he says is dedicated/focused on Ginty.

Look at the horse riding, the drunken speech and the "how do you like being kissed" scenes. Uncomfortable to watch.

Obviously Disney would never allow these kinds of implications to end up on screen but they're hard to ignore. I think Farrell and the writers got the character all wrong.

The point of the flashbacks is to show that Mrs. Travers loved her father, but her dad's relationship with her is borderline obssessive.

Anyone agree? Or am I crazy?

reply

[deleted]

Disagree. Nothing incestuous. A father's love, a daughter's love.

reply

Boy, these Americans are obsessed with kiddie porn!

nobody lives forever...

reply

The father is shown through the daughter's point of view, that's why all the flash-backs seems to be all about them.

And what the hell? Incest?? Come on...

reply

[deleted]

I just watched the movie and I had the same reaction. I can’t believe they had a father-daughter riding scene where she’s sitting embracing and facing him on a galloping horse. That is wholly inappropriate. It’s disgustingly suggestive, especially with the slow-motion, up and down movements.
The conversation about shaving, too, was sickening. Father and daughter were portrayed as obsessed with each other. To those who see no wrong in this, fine; but these scenes ruined the movie for me.

reply