MovieChat Forums > Ginger & Rosa (2012) Discussion > Elle VS Dakota's acting abilities

Elle VS Dakota's acting abilities


Elle's authentic accent and authentic acting as English pubescent girl in Ginger amd Rosa was far superior than her older sister's english poor accent performance in Now is Good! Elle just might be a better actress than Dakota.

reply

I've always thought that while watching Dakota it feels like you're watching a very well trained actor and while watching Elle it feels like you're watching a natural.

reply

I also agree with you both. Elle is definitely the better actor, at least presently.

reply

yeppers so true. But dakota was real good as a kid. i just watched this not long ago & saw ur post insick while on Elysium board and wanted to comment & say hey cause i never go on that other board anymore. wow wee those women are nutso on there lol! when I saw this movie i kept thinking how good the other actress is named Alice englert I think her name is. she was in beautiful creatures. she's also REALLY PRETTY & was crushing on her the entire movie hehe.

reply

I think that we can see in Elle's case is that she is clearly getting better in better in each role. But I am missing the same in Dakota's case.

reply

I was going to make a similar comment. It's not like Dakota is over-trained, but yeah, "Now is Good" she was good, but it did seem like she was a good *actor*. I have almost always thought Elle was better, and then felt guilty for comparing them lol. Elle is truly amazing though. Her crying scene was just epic. I talk when I'm crying just the same way.

reply

Elle is a better actress than her sister. She has more range and better talent.

reply

I am not surprised by the Elle love fest here on an Elle movie
Dakota is better.

she showed in Runaways she could sing and transform into Cheri,Now is good (a british speach coach even admitted that Dakota was better than Elle in her english accent), Hounddog,secret life of bees ect..



CW network sucks ass!

reply

Dakota was perfect in THE RUNAWAYS.

reply

Sorry I gotta go with Elle, she's also prettier.

reply

Dakota's never happy anymore. She's so stiff nowadays. Elle has more fun in her acting.

reply

yeah Dakota does seem that way and choose a lot of roles like that also. I would date her, though, so someone hook me up. lol.

reply

Elle is better, but I like them both.

reply

Elle really caught my attention with this performance, just outstanding. She's a natural, her sister, not so much.

reply

Their acting talent is probably equal, but Elle Fanning is usually better cast. She's in a lot of films like "Neon Demon" that are very visual and take advantage of her striking looks, but don't really require any tour-de-force acting. Dakota Fanning takes on more challenging roles really, but she often doesn't pull them off. She wasn't convincing as Cherie Currie in "The Runaways" and she's always very weak in any kind of "sexy" role like "The Last of Robin Hood".


"Let be be finale of seem/ The only emperor is the Emperor of Ice Cream"

reply