MovieChat Forums > Promised Land (2013) Discussion > He grew up on a farm in Iowa but he can'...

He grew up on a farm in Iowa but he can't operate a stick shift?


Come on

reply

I grew up on a farm in a very rural area. I know a lot of people that grew up on farms and can't drive a stick shift.

reply

so all your tractors. etc. were automatic?

reply

Isn't it a bit "racist" to assume all in Iowa are farmers :)? I'm sure there are lawyers, retailers, nurses, programmers etc there too.

reply

There's no assumption involved. He stated flat out he grew up on a farm in Iowa.

reply

Point taken.

reply

and it's not a racist remark

reply

Fail all around with your "racist" comment.

reply

I thought that was really odd too, I thought all rural people would know stuff like that but I am not American (where I read Automatics are verry popular) nor a farmer.

He definitely grew up on a farm as he says but he doesn't say his dad is farmer, his grandpa is, but then what does his dad do and...forgetaboutit.

reply

I wondered about that as well. I grew up in rural PA near Pittsburgh. We had 2 tractors -- one was a 1928; the other a 1932. We knew about clutches. You can drive farm equipment legally at a pretty young age (it might be age 14 by now, but we were driving at age 12).

reply

Growing up on a farm isn't the same as growing up to be a farmer. He mentioned he wanted to study something other than agriculture enough to fight with his grandfather about it, which suggests he wasn't interested in it, which in turn suggests he wouldn't be interested in learning anything more about it than any other kid. His chances of knowing how to drive a stick shift wouldn't be any higher than the average person's.

reply

i grew up in PA, and can not imagine relying an an automatic transmission in a car... sure, i have driven them, but i certainly learned ina stick shift.


i now live in iowa, and know quite a few people who live on working farms, who can not drive a stick shift car...

we do make fun of them though

reply

Agreed. I grew up in a rural area in Virginia. My dad's side of the family were farmers. I never had any desire to go into that line of work. I learned to drive early, but I learned on an automatic. Only a couple of family members in my generation (born in 60s-70s) or younger knew how to drive a stick. Just because you grew up in a rural area around farming doesn't mean that you were personally hopping on a tractor on a regular basis.

reply

I recommend learning. You never know when you have a chance to hop into a sports car.

I'm old. In driver's ed when I was 15, we spent 1/2 the time on a stick and 1/2 on an automatic. Sooooo glad. It's served me well through the years.

^^^
Absolutism is the enemy of resolution

reply

Is this where I say SPOILER ALERT?

In end he stays.

Bet he learns very quickly to drive a stick.

:~)



reply

[deleted]

People should go for their license on a manual transmission, then you should be able to drive both in an emergency. It's really America that is so predominantly automatic. Europe has as many manuals as America has autos, Australia is about even. I drive a 6 speed manual, it's far safer as you pay attention to what the car is doing and you can control your speed in traffic far more easily and precisely. Fewer manual drivers have rear end crashes, an interesting statistic.

reply

good thing we have 911 for emergencies!

seriously though, considering people still talk & text while driving, it's probably a good thing they aren't trying to switch gears as well.

reply

good think we have 911 for emergencies!

seriously though, considering people still talk & text while driving, it's probably a good thing they aren't trying to switch gears as well.

reply

Fluff, if your claim about crashes is true, that is interesting. I grew up in the suburbs of 2 big cities, learned on an automatic but then borrowed my oldest brother's VW Beetle and learned stick in a hurry. I'm now the last one in my family to still drive a stick. No stats, but I suspect my stick car (and it's gotten harder to find such critters) is less likely to get stolen since the average city thief nowadays probably can't drive one. That said, I will now go check to make sure it's still in the driveway!

I have seen enough to know I have seen too much. -- ALOTO

reply

I grew on a farm in Iowa. I do not know how to drive a stick shift.

I didn't farm. I didn't stick around to learn the "family" trade -- much like Matt Damon's character -- and there's never been any reason for me to know how to drive a stick shift.

My dad drove the tractors and pickup when I was a kid and then when I got a car it was an automatic.

As someone who has literally lived this scenario...it seems pretty logical to me.

reply

i think the reason he didn't know how to drive a stick shift is to show how out of touch and how much he hated the agro lifestyle that he came from.

reply

What I can't understand how in such a developed country like USA you can get a licence but not be able to drive a manual? It should be compulsory to do the test in a manual. It is real driving after all.

I am a very decisive person, I think.

reply

It's a statement about society in general. Typically, farmers, farmers' families, those who grew up on a farm, etc, have to work for a living. They're usually hard workers, from sunup to sundown kind of people. There's so much work to do on a farm and if everyone doesn't help it doesn't get done. They don't have time for video games, itunes, and sitting around on websites like this one debating about what life is really like for other people.

People who grow up in the city, on the other hand, usually have it a lot easier. If their mom isn't working three jobs to pay for their xbox, and cellphone bills then they're probably on welfare and using their EBT cards to pay for such things.
(And that's not a racial statement. The one person I'm closes to that fits that description is white - fat & white)

The point being, if you have a lot of work to do, and you can't sit around waiting for someone else to do it for you, then you get off your ass and do it. If that involves learning to drive a stick shift because that's the only type of vehicle your family can afford then that's what you do.

reply

My dad taught me how to drive both,he worked at a place that had multiple trucks with different gear ratios and that helped me a lot.My first job at fourteen was for a farmer and he had an early 80s ford pickup with a three on the tree,I never got the hang of that.The farmer was a major *beep* and if you didn't get it right the first time,it was "get out of the way I'll do it".
Tractors are a lot easier than cars,they are geared to the moon and are pretty hard to stall,even with the parking brake on(don't ask).

reply

The parking brake on, what do you mean? 


"I don't want to have a bloody avatar!" -paraphrased from BQQ's annoyances with IMDb's stupidity

reply