MovieChat Forums > Black Mirror (2011) Discussion > My thoughts and ratings for each episode...

My thoughts and ratings for each episode of Black Mirror


I binged Black Mirror in three weeks. It wasn’t too hard, there are not a lot of episodes and the show is a nice breath of fresh air so it’s easy to watch. Some very entertaining stuff right here let me tell ya! Im sad that I don’t have any more to watch. ☹
DOn't hesitate to compare your ratings/thoughts with mine, I would enjoy getting your feedback too.

Here are my quick notes and ratings for every season:

S1E1 THE NATIONAL ANTHEM:
Well, I did not expect that at all. Quite unique, I mean, I never saw anything like it before. The PM has to bang a pig or the Princess dies. Speechless I is. 7-7.5/10
S1E2 FIFTEEN MILLION MERITS:
Great atmosphere, creepy-hi-tech feel to it. I liked seeing the guy from Get Out again. 7.5-8/10
S1E3 THE ENTIRE HISTORY OF YOU:
Interesting idea, average execution. I can’t say I did not enjoy it. 6.5/10
Overall: 7/10

S2E1 BE RIGHT BACK:
Good execution, good acting, good story, no low no high, that’s the problem. 6.5-7/10
S2E2 WHITE BEAR:
An exhilarating ride from start to finish. It was intense and thrilling. I have my reserve concerning the final twist but it really got my blood pumping. 8-8.5/10
S2E3 THE WALDO MOMENT:
The script was not bad, the cinematography was nice but it’s probably the weakest link here. 6/10
S2E4 WHITE CHRISTMAS:
I liked the concept, some good ideas were offered here but I felt like the final punch was not as hard as it was meant to be. Hamm was solid in his role. 7.5/10
Overall: 7/10



S3E1 NOSEDIVE:
Might be my favorite concept yet and it was well exploited, especially thanks to some great acting and solid direction. The title fits the script perfectly. 8-8.5/10
S3E2 PLAYTEST:
It took a long time for it to get to the good part but the good part was GREAT! 7- 7.5/10
S3E3 SHUT UP AND DANCE:
Got me hooked from start to finish, and once more, what a finish! 8/10
S3E4 SAN JUNIPERO:
Very soft for a Black Mirror episode but still a good concept that was well executed. Both actresses were great. 7/10
S3E5 MEN AGAINST FIRE:
Awesomely bloody and clever episode. Yet another great surprise. 7.5-8/10
S3E6 HATED IN THE NATION:
This 1h29m episode felt like a mix between an ‘’afternoon TV flick’’ and a Black Mirror classic. Good acting, good script but the whole thing looks a bit cheap. 7/10
Overall: 7.5-8/10



-S4E1 USS CALLISTER:
Ingenious, fun, captivating and well played. 8-8.5/10
-S4E2 ARKANGEL:
Clever idea, drab and boring execution. 5-5.5/10
-S4E3 CROCODILE:
Good, entertaining, shot in nice settings. 7/10
-S4E4 HANG THE DJ:
Skillfully executed, well played and an epic twist on the typical love story. (My favorite episode of the show) 9/10
-S4E5 METALHEAD:
Succeed in its attempt but does not manage to elevate itself above simple goodness. 7/10
-S4E6 BLACK MUSEUM:
Great atmosphere, awesome mini-stories, cool story, monkey loves you. 8.5/10
Overall: 7.5/10

reply

I'm up to episode 3 (S4) Crocodile.
I have to say I found this one so disturbing right from the very beginning. A terribly uncomfortable "what would you do?" scenario spiralling hideously out of control.

I saw the first 2 seasons a while ago and loved them.
I didn't finish season 3 because I didn't particularly enjoy the first 2 episodes.It's back on form now it seems.

reply

I pretty much agree with all of your ratings. Except I'd rate the first two episodes of season one much lower. My top three episodes are:

San Junipero
Playtest
Uss callister

reply

I disagree with most your scores. Just seen them all. To be honest, I could just as well have been good by never seeing most of them.

reply

That's too bad bruh.

reply

Actually I agree (or very close to agreeing with you) on the scores for The Entire History of You, Be Right Back, The Waldo Moment, Arkangel, White Christmas, and San Junipero.

Every other episode, I would rate significantly lower. Or even way lower, in regards to the first two, Nosedive, Hated In The Nation, USS Callister and Crocodile.

My top 3:

San Junipero - 7.5
White Christmas - 7
Be Right Back - 7

I might actually like Be Right Back the best due to being perhaps the only episode (aside from San Junipero) I didn't find either dull at parts, or annoying me a lot regarding how far fetched it is. White Christmas is very well made, but sadly it's also way too far fetched for me to be able to give it a higher score.

Season 4 is also easily the worst. Ever episode aside from the pointless Metalhead uses the same body chip transfer gimmick in some way as an integral part of the story.

reply

I liked the body chip thing. I thought it glued the show together well.


You actually liked Be right back and San Junipero more than me. So at least it's that.

Good talk.

reply

[deleted]

My Top 3:
1. White Christmas
2. San Junipero
3. Shut up and dance
Honorable Mention: Hang the DJ

reply

these things are, of course, always subjective
that said, my favorite episodes:

the entire history of you (ignorance used to be bliss)
white christmas (of human blockage)
playtest (lebowski meets spiderman or beware inscrutable worthy oriental developer gentleman)
men against fire (plug in palestinians or iranians, just for kicks)
hated in the nation (ted kaczynski w/ mad it skills)
uss callister (the adventures of james t jerk)
hang the dj (brownian dating)

reply