MovieChat Forums > Barfi! (2012) Discussion > An answer for all 'Barfi' haters...

An answer for all 'Barfi' haters...


Last night i saw "barfi" and i found it quite good.let me tell you how i found it more appealing.

when you see an Indian movie,please omit some Hollywood *beep* from your mind that you are watching a copied material,it might be copied but see the efforts of director who presented an already told story in a new way with his mind creation and added some more to same topic.

2ndly,i am also a very strict rating viewer on IMDb,there are very rare films whom i rated 10,a very rare whom i rated 9,but this film had my 8,and you know why?director made his way through this.

the cinematography,the light effects,the sound tracks,the expressions by actors,and the set itself was superb at some places.in my view director created his very good masterpiece and represented it in oriental style blended with serene perfection and the old yellow screen touch.

so in my view,this was superb,i don't mind copying any concept,when you present it in much better view.so when you plan to see an Indian movie,please for a moment forget that you are ABCD or BBCD and see the Indian film just being an Urdu viewer and then rate it,i hope then you would be better able to see the film and praise the efforts of director.never mind when you see a Hollywood film,then become an expert from that point of view.if i start rating Indian film with Hollywood mindset,it would be same like if i say American is for Red Indians,and all the whites should pack their stuff and get lost.So stop racism on forums,be open minded and accept someone's efforts and see the perfection he blended with his mind into a picture presented to you.

we are those people who sit on YouTube,start racism there,Indians are this,Pakistanis are this,and then when we go to Western countries and become victim of racism,then we yell,racism is bad.why to scream then,when you inflicted racism and made it your motto then bear the racism of Blacks.i am Pakistani but i have an open heart and mind for everyone who has an open mind to work on any good topic.if i become racist then i am no worse than everyone who sees porn on web and yell in media stop it,break traffic laws and sit in parliament and yell there is no law,use cell phone while driving and scream cell phones are to be banned while driving.

this film was enough good to give me 2.30hrs of entertainment,and i got my 2.30hrs properly utilized with happiness,yes when i see a Hollywood film i also have same mind set,there are still some Hollywood films which i would rate as crap.

reply

Dude, what the *beep* is this? Porn, racism, pakistan, traffic laws, parliament? Are you on pot?

My five year plan; Do not die.

reply

most likely American, so if you want to communicate with them, you must limit yourself to two syllables per word and three sentences per paragraph.

Throw in a few "I tells ya what fo" too.

I live here. I know well.

ps: any movie that doesn't contain at least one certified psycho (preferably trying to glorify him/her) has no chance with them anyway.

reply

Where the *beep* did the director copy the story, which other movie has the same story? The director copied some scenes from some movies yes, but the whole concept NO!!!!!. Look at this way, he had to include a talk between mother and daughter for 5 min, so he could have done that over a table, near the railway tracks, near a playground where the kids are playing etc, but he couldn't come up with something original hence the notebook scene which makes more sense than the others above. Same for some of the other scenes as well. But the story as a whole is *beep* different. The setting, the cinematography, the dialogues, the side stories, ranbir's and priyanka's acting and the music...ohh the music are just mind blowing.

reply

its not a comment about any movie topic instead it looks like someone is emotionally hurt.

reply