MovieChat Forums > Project Runway All Stars (2012) Discussion > no more past winners on all stars please...

no more past winners on all stars please


they need to stop bringing in the past winners from their season into all stars.
It seems like all past winners who join all stars win it too. we want the playing field to be leveled.
LOVED dom last look I really want that skirt.
Kini blue bubble dress stunning
Ken cream jacket stunning

reply

That's just stupid. I want to see talented people do well and win if they are the best. I don't want to see only losers.

-
Consider the daffodil. And while you're doing that I'll be over here looking through your stuff.

reply

It's not stupid. It's actually more interesting to see a whole cast of those looking for redemption. Former winners winning again gets boring.

reply

Like the poster above said the point of the series is to see great designs. You can't just invite weak designers and have boring outfits.

reply

People that have been cut the first time around weren't always weak designers just like some that have won haven't all been great designers. Some people have lost unfairly in team challenges when their teammate had immunity, for example.

Those that want a second chance have more at stake than those that already have a win. So wanting to see designers try t overcome their loss is more exciting than watching someone phone it in like Dom and Dmitry.

reply

I'd rather see the best compete against each other not the worst. If that means a winner competes, I'm all for it. That's like saying to someone "Hey, you win a gold medal the last Olympics. You can't compete this year. Give someone else a chance."

reply

Exactly! And just because you're a past winner doesn't mean you have an advantage. Look at Jeffrey and irina.

reply

Yes! Not all past winners will win

reply