I always hate


when past winners win All Stars. I feel it's unfair to even have them back. I feel like Ken should have won. Dom already one, Kini's collection was ugly, so that left Ken open, at least to me. I like both Dom and Kini and rooted for them on their seasons but...

reply

Either have no former winners to give them a chance to win, or have all past winners to pick the best of the best.

Mixing former winners and losers is silly.

reply

I agree completely.

"Two gin and Frescas"
"Shaken, not ridiculed"

reply

Agreed. It just seems so greedy to have past winners come and win :/

reply

Yea. Like last season. I loved Dmitry on his season of PR but was disappointed he was invited back and won All Stars. I feel winners had their chance, give someone else a shot. Like another person said if you're gonna have All Stars, have either all winners or all contestants who had not won. I wasn't even happy to see Dom win despite loving her on her season because someone else should have gotten it. How can you really be happy for someone that's won it already?

reply

I have no issue with it when they deserve it, but dmitrys collection was nothing new of fresh. Sonjay totally deserved to win. Still bitter about it.

reply

I totally agree about Dimitry's collection. He was so arrogant to boot and everything he made looked like tacky ice skating outfits.


I liked Ken's collection a lot more than Kini's. Kini is one note -- ruffles on the side, ruffles in the front, ruffles in the back. It was very 80s and not in a good way.

reply

Yes! I also am super confused by his choice of plaid and in those colors. I feel like he must be really trying to be known for something other than denim now but he was SO GOOD WITH DENIM. Oy it looked like he was trying to make 80s clothes for sure

reply

As soon as they said Ken's line was the most commercial, I knew he was doomed and wound up 2nd runner up! A real shame since he came back and performed quite admirably; with designing and dealing with his frustrations and the people! Good for him! ;-/

- http://fiero4251.blogspot.com/2011/06/project-runway-fashion-show-from-1107-on.html -

- - http://www.childrenofrassilon.com/fiero425.html - - homepage

reply

I think it's fine to have a past winner. If they won again, good for them. It means everyone else needs to step up their game.

reply

Wow, OTTH 3 seasonal winners took an all-star comp; only Anthony Ryan & Mondo newbies to the winner's club! ;-/

- http://fiero4251.blogspot.com/2011/06/project-runway-fashion-show-from-1107-on.html -

- - http://www.childrenofrassilon.com/fiero425.html - - homepage

reply

[deleted]