About that ending


We see them in a ski lift: Simon is going up and she is going down. Does this mean anything? A pointer? Seems like a deliberate open ending, and I must admit that I cannot think of a better way to wrap up this story.


(Copied from a review here.)

I don't think the choreography, them railing in opposite directions, has any significance. The ending I think just wanted to show that she does start to think and worry about him (in a maternal way) and so goes and look for him. He spends the night up in the cabin station if I got that right, breaks into crying but (not unlike in a toilet scene prior, his face bruised, fists clenching) runs downslope determined to make a living [all himself] in his world.

As I see it the ending is about both characters growing up and facing the reality. She won't stay up there, I'm sure she comes down with the next cabin.

reply

I can't see it as anything but tragic. In fact, I still am not convinced this scene is "really" happening - we saw the entire resort shutting down just moments before, with the ski lifts stopping and everything. Could this just be Simon's imagination? His unconscious? He and Louise are going in opposite directions, forever peering out at each others' passing figures through a barrier of glass. I just don't see much hope here.

reply

Ski resorts shut down at the end of the skiing season. It's a seasonal way of living for the workers who move on and look for work elsewhere. It is/was a seasonal occupation for Simon too, depending on how you interpret the ending.

For me it ends pretty hopefully. Why would Louise be in that cabin at the end if not looking for Simon? Out of worry I think.

reply

It's really happening. There are two ski lifts, We only see how the highest one stops, not the lower, red one

reply

When Simon hugged Kristin (Gillian Anderson), Louise realized she has never been a mother to him (and probably never will be one). There's no clue which indicates that they will continue with their lives together. Sad ending but quite realistic.


http://i.imgur.com/cLmHP.jpg

reply

I think it is very good way of finish the history. In a minute, the director shows what've happened in the movie and what will happen to the characters: the mother goes to the solitude and the son will begin a new life.

It is one of the most significat final scenes I've seen

I'm sorry if my english is not very correct

reply

I think the choreography is quite significant, symbolically. The film is actually titled "The child from on high" in its original and has played throughout with the notion that Simon gets by in part by both craving to be a part of the social world "on high" - the one time he himself uses the phrase "en haut" ("on high") in the film is to rationalize that 'those people' are oblivious to his stealings and represent a world where money is easy and things are always replaceable - and also making his own 'living' (such as it is) off those well-heeled "on high" - and also inserting himself in it, at times facilely and at times very awkwardly and blatantly out of sync with it.

His "sister" has no such comfort zone "on high" (although "comfort zone" isn't quite the right term for him either - as brazenly as he zips in and out with his loot, almost as smoothly as one skiing through mogels, there is nevertheless a kind of constant tension we sense and occasionally see surface when he finds himself caught red-handed. Its implicit that she would not be able to pass herself off as from 'on high' and while more than content to live off his means, she also doesn't seem to display the same brazenness that makes him so independent a creature amongst them. She also lights up at a prospect of becoming one of them but by winning over well-heeled lovers, yet with a degree of dependence that is a relic of traditional gender roles - and which plays out even in their "sibling" dynamic as she lets him be the breadwinner and where she allows herself to blow his hard-"earned" booty.

(SPOILER ALERT)

So when we see them passing in opposite directions on the ski lift, he coming down from "on high," it's not coincidence that, when she finally acts on a maternal instinct and need to find him, it's a moment that has led her to go searching for him in his adopted world on high just as he is resurrecting himself from his despair and sense of complete abandonment at ski season's end and heading down - to the world he was born into, his modus operandi now inoperative for the foreseeable future. He is descending from his false-self manipulation of that world 'on high' to have to find a new m.o., while feeling the failure of a would-be emotional fantasy with the English mother he 'adopted', whose affection he has blown and lost, and thinking he is also now totally alone in the world as his real mother had already abandoned him too, with words of rebuke and resentment of his existence.

Their passing in opposing ski lift cabins provides (as well as the symbolism of their respective uphill-downhill m.o.s for survival) a way to depict symbolically the gulf between these two, where survival drives have made them mutually suspect of each other's true priorities (he especially of hers) and there has been ruptured trust between them that has played out in ongoing ways, creating walls and seemingly unbridgeable gap of two passing cable cars, but they are glass walls that allow them to see each other and to pound their buried emotional bond, their respective vulnerabilities, with their open palms on the glass toward one another. To me, it is a moment of rebirth, especially for Simon who has perhaps never seen such a potent sign that he genuinely matters - enough to be searched for by someone who knows him just enough to know to look for him "on high."

reply