The Big Picture for this Remake


When I saw that SyFy had done a remake of a movie that had been done twice before, the original and the much better knock off The Final Countdown, I was disappointed. To see SyFy rehashing previously done content was a disappointment when there are so many original stories out there that could be executed well, and within the kinds of budgets available to this independent (studio-wise) channel.

My second disappointment, though largely unavoidable because of budgetary constraints, are the recycled Vancouver actors that have graced Stargate-SG1, Stargate Atlantis, Stargate Universe, Sanctuary, Battlestar Galactica and a host of other Sci-Fi/SyFy series. Don't get me wrong, most are fine actors who inhabit science fiction/fantasy properties very well. However seeing the same faces recycled so often easily forces viewers to suspend their suspension of disbelief.

The last comment I have about SyFy productions concerns the paucity of non-white faces seen on-screen to the extent that when one appears it's patently obvious that they were deliberately inserted in an effort to combat the very issue I mention. This is one bi-racial writer's opinion, and will not necessarily be agreed upon by many who read this. And looking at the demographics of Vancouver, B.C., you have to use what's at hand. :-)

I have carefully watched the SyFy channel struggle with profitability for over a decade now, and redoing The Philadelphia Experiment with today's special effects, current "scientific/science fiction" nomenclature and casting Michael Pare in a nod to the original, provided a brief measure of interest, but overall the abiding review for me came down to SSDD.

The execution of this made-for-TV movie was creditable, and probably made the plot more accessible to today's younger viewers, but I would have liked to have seen SyFy skip this remake in favor of producing something original.

reply

when there are so many original stories out there that could be executed well

By Syfy? You'd really like to have the next round of Sharktopus vs. Cactubear? At least this way half the script is already written and you don't have to listen to the actors make up the dialog on the spot.

Don't get me wrong, most are fine actors who inhabit science fiction/fantasy properties very well. However seeing the same faces recycled so often easily forces viewers to suspend their suspension of disbelief.

This is where your suspension of disbelief breaks down? Did you watch the movie?
You see the same actors over and over because they live nearby and will work for the next nothing budget Syfy is willing to expend.

I should mention I thought this was a bit above par for a Syfy movie. 4/10.

---
"Dawn's in trouble. Must be Tuesday."

reply

Not to mention 'The Final Countdown' came out in 1980, four years before the first production of 'The Philadelphia Experiment,' so I don't see how it is a "knockoff."

reply

Thank You! The Final Countdown was a great flick and had NOTHING to do with The Philadelphia Experiment, other than a Navy ship. The two stories are unrelated, even though some viewers point to a handful of similarities about time-travel, or electromagnetism, or whatever. An honest reviewer knows the plots are very different.

=========
wait for iiiiit...

reply

I love that they use those 'recycled' Canadian actors and if they make a big version of this, I would like nothing more than to see Emilie Ullerup in it. She is a good actress and beautiful to boot.

Oh gravity, thou art a heartless bitch!

reply