MovieChat Forums > The Reluctant Fundamentalist (2013) Discussion > Why are they playing Hindu music in a mo...

Why are they playing Hindu music in a movie about some Pakistani guy ?


Stupid Trailer makers.



Last movie seen -
Zero Dark Thirty: 10/10
Django Unchained: 10/10
Vishwaroopam: 10/10




reply


Sitar Bansuri duet from Pakistan

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrvqIE6Sgtc

reply

They're Pakistanis playing Indian music. This kind of music makes it more accessible to the general public as Indian music is more popular, and makes it seem like every brown person is from India. It's a gross inaccuracy. I know they're from Pakistan, but they chose to use music that's more assocatiated with Indians since India is more popular.

reply

wrong

reply

ppl already cant differentiate b/w Hindus and Muslims and the music used in the trailer does not help

Last movie seen -
Zero Dark Thirty: 10/10
Django Unchained: 10/10
Vishwaroopam: 10/10




reply

^^^it's more about between Indians and Pakistanis, but essentially you're right. They chose this sitar group to satisfy their own marketing interests (let's have Indian music, cuz that's what ALL brown's people's music is) and Pakistanis by having Pakistanis play Indian music. They couldn't use something more distinctly Pakistani cuz Hollywood thinks it's easier to stereotype all brown people as "Indian" or align all brown people with India as subtle racism since India used to be a British colony, and is most affiliated with white people.

Let's hope the film doesn't use more of this style of music. I'd prefer a traditional Hollywood score over Indian music.

reply

are you seriously not aware that indian/pakistan were the same thing under the british raj?

reply

I know, but Pakistan separated from their rule and went under a new name. I know India did too, but they stayed as India and didn't change the names of their major cities until much later.

Regardless...they're just using typical Indian music to represent all South Asian culture, when that's not the case.

But whatever, you seem to have an anti-Pakistani, anti-Muslim agenda here. I dunno if you're Indian, but I would think even Indians would be like WTF as Hollywood is telling the world that this music is Pakistani.

reply

punjabi culture dates back 5000 years to the indus valley civilization. pakistan and india came into existence 60 years ago. 5000 years of history say punjabi culture is punjabi culture. it's gonna take a lot more than 60 years to change that...

reply

'punjabi culture dates back 5000 years to the indus valley civilization. pakistan and india came into existence 60 years ago. 5000 years of history say punjabi culture is punjabi culture. it's gonna take a lot more than 60 years to change that...'

👍

It's that man again!!

reply

'punjabi culture dates back 5000 years to the indus valley civilization. pakistan and india came into existence 60 years ago. 5000 years of history say punjabi culture is punjabi culture. it's gonna take a lot more than 60 years to change that...'


you watched the film too on bbc

It's the same with Bengal and Bangladesh,

the partition was called the Radcliffe Line

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radcliffe_Line


from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partition_of_India

Of the violence that accompanied the Partition of India, historians Ian Talbot and Gurharpal Singh write:

There are numerous eyewitness accounts of the maiming and mutilation of victims. The catalogue of horrors includes the disembowelling of pregnant women, the slamming of babies' heads against brick walls, the cutting off of victims limbs and genitalia and the display of heads and corpses. While previous communal riots had been deadly, the scale and level of brutality was unprecedented. Although some scholars question the use of the term 'genocide' with respect to the Partition massacres, much of the violence manifested as having genocidal tendencies. It was designed to cleanse an existing generation as well as prevent its future reproduction."[42]

reply

nobbleq and co. You folks just went FULL RETARD!! Unbelievable! With the vast expanse of facts and information available at only a touch or voice away, it's simply mind-blowing how somebody could make such a comment. Perhaps you are Straight-jacketed convicts in orange boiler suits held at the state penal insane asylum. There's no other explanation for your ignorance.

But if you are regular folks like most of the world... a quiet word, if I may... look, going retard is fine, every now and then we all do it... but never go Full Retard. NEVER! And even if you do have the twitches and spasms with a mindless mess of madness talk from your mouth,never ever do it online

reply

To the idiots who think that the music wasn't Pakistani... Are you kidding me? Could you give me a few examples of what exactly does Pakistani music sound like?
Because as a Pakistani myself, I couldn't tell the difference!!!
Missed your history classes?
Pak and India DO share similar music, similar food and somewhat similar customs and traditions... so for you to come here and talk this nonsense is frankly, ludicrous!!!

reply

Howsoever you may try to pretend to be Arabs/Persians or try to Wahabise yourself, the factual situation is that Arabs don't give two hoots to Pakis.. Go to Saudi and try to pass off as an Arab.. Tell them that you are real Arabs and want to marry an Arab.
You can replace Khuda Hafiz with Allah Hafiz, but that won't make you Arabs..

Except for few nostalgic Punjabis and Sindhis in India, Indians themselves don't want to associate anymore with Terrorist hub called Pakistan. Notwithstanding the fact that it is impossible to deny the fact that atleast 80% of Pakistanis have Hindu/Buddhist/Indian ancestory, and you can drain all your blood out and transfuse with Arab/Persian blood, but your genes won't be able to lie..

Anyways, good luck with blowing your Pakistani Music



reply

You seem to equate muslim=arab, which is ignorant. Far more ignorant than hindi=pakistani.

reply

May be the brotherly advices to poor South Asian muslim by an arab in this video will educate you about the real great muslim music

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sm5mGGJ_jXE&feature=youtu.be

reply

The lyrics of the songs were from Pakistani poet Faiz Ahmed Faiz. The music by Peter Gabriel. The musicians Indian, Pakastani and Western. The music on the trailer means nothing, it's just a trailer.



reply

They're Punjabis aren't they? Since when were Pakistan and India divided so clearly!? Here's what I want to say to you, IF you are either f* ing Paki, or what's the best pejorative for a f* ing Indian?? Death to you and the likes of you, for being so seduced by the greater Imperialist power's divisions of the world; Pakistan and India in this case! (Yes, all peoples are so similar, some more kashmerical than others)... It's just so great how nations and peoples are divided, huh? Worked a charm in Korea... hurumph!

reply

Its Pakistani music originally sung in Coke studio Pakistan. You can youtube it.

reply

I could swear that I heard Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan and is brother; they are Pakistani ... am I wrong?
I realize that Nusrat has passed, but I assumed that maybe they used a previous recording or something
current sung by his brother; it really made the movie for me

"You're watching too much Sopranos, when you give your kids their allowance in envelopes"

reply