MovieChat Forums > The Broken Circle Breakdown (2012) Discussion > Does anybody else share this opinion?...

Does anybody else share this opinion?...


I think this is a good movie. Would have been great if I was a country fan.
I find the endtune they play at the hospital when Elise/Alabama dies, unfitting to the mood of the scene.
It kind of ruined it. Here we have a sad moment which is dressed up like a carnaval where people cheer to their banjo's as if it's a new years eve party.
If I was Didier at that moment I would be unable to play such a cheerful melody even if I tried it to suppress the sadness.
My mind just wouldn't be capable of being cheerful.
Maybe it's just me.

Need harmonic brainwaves to soothe your diligent mind? Visit bryanel.com and relax!

reply

I would say more than half the people would agree with you but I thought it fit. Great movie.

reply

I thought it was perfect

----
Top 75 Favorite Movies(25 movies added):http://www.imdb.com/list/dDDa_qSKRxw/

reply

I see your point but Didier decided to stay true to the same music that he, Elise and the rest of the band had played and loved when she was with them.

reply

I felt like they wanted to give the best "finale" to her.
Honoring their time together with a song that represented them.
She wouldve been glad if there was afterlife.

reply