Why is this in the top 250?


Really, it shouldn't be. But I guess the top 250 is already messed up enough.

reply

Easy, because there isn't 250 more movies out there that are better than this one. You don't like it but everyone else does. Move along.

reply

Easy, because there isn't 250 more movies out there that are better than this one.
Yes there are, you seem to be under the impression that the top 250 is anything more than a popularity contest.

reply

Not an impression, mate. Those that dwell on these boards have spoken with their votes. In this world, it's a top 250 film. In different conditions (which aren't here) could be different.

reply

In this world, it's a top 250 film.

On this website.

reply

Sadly, standards have fallen.

reply

That is a subject of debate. Films that inspire teamwork, fun story, interesting characters, and entertaining fit the bill for G.A. Nothing wrong with that standard either.

reply

fun story

A very generic and cliche story.

interesting characters

Some interesting enough, some bland and underdeveloped.

reply

Actually, you're the one who's bland.

reply

Agreed, bored me to death this movie... Took me 4-5 sessions to finish it!

reply

Seriously? Personally, the ONLY two movies where I've had that experience were Diamonds Are Forever (I was marathoning James Bond movies throughout July two years ago) and A Millions Ways To Die In The West (I only kept watching it because of my friend's recommendation... it didn't get better,) and I've seen quite a lot of movies. Guardians Of The Galaxy, however, isn't even close to having to watch in multiple sessions.

reply

This.

reply

Agreed

reply

"On this website."

Yes stupid phock which website did you think you were posting on?

reply

[deleted]

“Think of how stupid the average person is, and realize half of them are stupider than that.”


― George Carlin

reply

Yes there are, you seem to be under the impression that the top 250 is anything more than a popularity contest.


Um..yeah? Whether a movie is good or bad is 100% subjective. Most people liking is what makes it a good movie.

reply

It is precisely a popularity contest.

Movies are made to entertain, therefore the only logical way to rank them is by asking the audience which movies entertained them. Insisting on some other criteria is ridiculous.

Zombie Squad: We make dead things deader...

reply

When you learn not all movies are made to entertain maybe you won't be so narrow minded about the criteria to rate them. Not saying that your rating system is bad, but acting like your opinion is the only one that matters is ridiculous.

reply

He's not acting like his opinion is the only one that matters? He said "most people liking it" is what matters.... And he's right.

You are in fact the one acting like only your opinion matters as you are incapable of understanding that whether you feel the movie should be in the top 250 or not, the fact that the majority of people do is what counts.

There are plenty of movies in the top 250 which I think are boring and I could hardly consider entertainment, but I respect the fact that a lot of others do and that makes me appreciate that it deserves to be in the position it is.

Stop acting like an elitist idiot on a movie database message board. You are a nobody like the rest of us, or you wouldn't be wasting your time here. Get your head out of the clouds and come back down to Earth where most of us live.

reply

What are they for then?

reply

Yes there are, you seem to be under the impression that the top 250 is anything more than a popularity contest.
Hey! Answered your own question. Well played, sir.

reply

I was more of complaining; not really asking anything.

*Duke

reply

What else is it except a popularity contest

reply

[deleted]

Because people voted so, doh.

reply

Do you actually think I'm asking about it? don't you think that maybe I'm just complaining?

reply

Do you actually think I'm asking about it? don't you think that maybe I'm just complaining?


Complaining implies that the standing of this film on the top 250 somehow negatively effects your life. If that's true, then this is either one of the worst cases of "1st world problems" ever, or it's incredibly pathetic. Find something important to get hung up on for a change.

reply

Don't feed it!

reply

You see, you are mistaking someone with a different opinion than you with a troll, a common mistake.

reply

Not a different opinion, just someone who disagrees with the majority to get a rise out of them. When the film took so much money, enjoyed by an audience of millions, you are seriously questioning why its in the top 250.

Most trolls use this line to justify their baiting!
You see, you are mistaking someone with a different opinion than you with a troll, a common mistake."

reply

Thats nice dear, just except that opinions vary and move on.

reply

No way, I'm on a crusade to rid these boards of hairy palmed little trolls.

reply

Don't feed it!
Oops, aw well, better luck next time.

reply

Thats nice dear, just except that opinions vary and move on.


accept

reply

I already know, and your post is pointless, but as long as you are having fun.

reply

I accept that The Dark Knight is highly rated, despite the fact that I personally hate it. We can't all agree with the masses.

In the kingdom of the blind, you're the village idiot.

reply

Why don't you like it just curios

reply

Sorry, I never noticed your comment to me. I don't like the Dark Knight for too many reasons, but chief among them, Batman was a loser who quits at the end. The Joker had all the power and got Batman to slink back in the shadows, Gordon to falsify evidence and basically lie, and corrupted and murdered Harvey Dent. Plus, I found it a chore to watch.

In the kingdom of the blind, you're the village idiot.

reply

You know all those complaints are plot points that bring us into TDKR, right?

reply

Make your own top 250. Then post it. So we can sh*t all over you

reply

Why would I do that? you are going to disagree with it anyways just because you want a fight.

reply

I get your point, I've got nothing against GOTG... is a very good movie, but it doesn't deserve a spot on the top 250. To take just one example, Kramer vs. Kramer is not included in the 250, now that's something beyond me.

reply

This is a lot more deserving to be in the top 250 than a lot of gone trash in there

reply

Soon. The IMDB top 250 will be rid of it.

reply

I don't think Shawshank Redemption is the best movie every made, but it is number one on the IMDB top 250. I liked it, but it was nowhere near that great. These things are based on votes by IMDB users, so it more a popularity rating than a reflection of quality. The quality of some films in the top 250 is warranted. I liked GotG, and gave it a high rating. The problem with the IMDB system is it should reflect more than one number. Perhaps one for entertainment value, artistic merit, etc.

reply