MovieChat Forums > Monsieur Lazhar (2012) Discussion > The Tree and the Chrysalis by Bachir Laz...

The Tree and the Chrysalis by Bachir Lazhar


After an unjust death, there's nothing to say. Nothing at all. As will become plain below.

From the branch of an olive tree there hung a tiny chrysalis the colour of an emerald. Tomorrow it would be a butterfly, freed from its cocoon. The tree was happy to see his chrysalis grown but secretly he wanted to keep her for a few more years. So long as she remembers me. He'd shielded her from gusts, saved her from ants. But tomorrow she would leave to confront predators and poor weather alone. That night, a fire ravaged the forest and the chrysalis never became a butterfly. At dawn, the ashes cold, the tree stood still but his heart was charred, scarred by the flames, scarred by grief. Ever since then when a bird alights on the tree, the tree tells it all about the chrysalis that never woke up. He pictures her, wings spread, flitting across a clear blue sky, drunk on nectar and freedom. The discreet witness to our love stories.

Fatima had a fetish for a wiggle in her scoot

reply

This part made me somewhat proud of the film, I expected a cliche inspiring speech, but it's bittersweet realism added to the authenticity of the movie.

reply

I agree. The words and their delivery by the actor were poetic and sorrowful without being schmaltzy or sentimental. I loved this film.

Fatima had a fetish for a wiggle in her scoot

reply

a very nice story that is reflecting on his wife and daughters death and also his students goodbye.

reply

Truly brilliant! It brings tears to my eyes every single time. This story and all those silent moments are what made it sincere and beautiful. Thank you for posting this.

reply

You're welcome. It's a wonderful story/parable from a wonderful film.

A bird sings and the mountain's silence deepens.

reply