Warriors


There's so many topics covered here: the heroic narrative, the way of the warrior [Bushido], tribal nationalism, asymmetrical warfare, masculinity, traditionalism, honor, morality, spirituality, vengeance, colonialism etc. etc. The Seediq Bale seem similar to indigenous tribes like the Shawnee and Maori as far as I can tell. Comparisons could probably be made between Mona Radau and Tecumseh.

This film was brutal and definitely not politically correct. I suspect many westerners are going to be turned off by it. The only real complaints I have with it are the translations going to *beep* as part 2 progressed and the non-editing out of about 10-15 minutes worth of scenes that would've made the whole thing come together more fluidly. Still, it's 4 1/2 hours of my life that I don't regret losing forever. ;)

I finished reading Jack Donovan's The Way of Men a month ago and I'm reading Phantom Soldier by H. John Poole (which is basically an overview of Oriental 4th generation warfare) so I'm finding a lot of similarities. Clint Eastwood's Letters from Iwo Jima would probably be a good addition to the three, if anyone wants to investigate the aforementioned topics further.

reply

It's tiring having to hear "westerners".

Sorry to break the news, but most people are not turned off by something that isn't politically correct. The west has loads of movies, shows and books that are not politically correct. Taking a loud minority for a majority is silly.

reply

You're tired? Then take a nap.

Westerners are turned on by ethnic nationalism and brutal human sacrifice? Also school shootings, primitivist patriarchal warrior societies, traditionalism, mass suicide and honor? Gotcha.

reply