Well I didn't love it, but I didn't hate it either.
I feel like I'm on the fence about this movie. Yes, there were some unrealistic plot points, but let's face it most movies have them (especially love stories).
I really felt like there was a lack of chemistry and passion between Kate Winslet & Josh Brolin. Maybe that's it.
I really hated her neighbor...and cringed when she slapped that poor boy. I guess we aren't supposed to like her though.