MovieChat Forums > Girl Fight (2011) Discussion > she kind of deserved it

she kind of deserved it


The reason I think this is because

1. She was too desperate to be popular and even began to be mean to her little sister, disrespect her parents and be disobedient. Imagine if she continued to be popular how unruly she would have become to her parents?

2. She dumped and ignored her best friend to be with a clique.

3. She had no right saying stuff at the lunch table like "not too classy either"...she already had a attitude towards most of the girls except for Alexa....And those girls picked up on it. she had a attitude with most of those girls from the start and only wanted to be friends with Alexa. Her attitude is what got those girls not liking her.

4. When Lauren asked Haley in the restroom "what does she mean Haley?" about Dana telling her she does not like any of the girls and after what she wrote about them on her face book wall. Haley should have known Lauren was going to log into Dana's page and check the wall and find it. She should have gone home and deleted those comments on Dana's wall asap.

5. She says to Dana after being cruel enough to dump her for a group of cliques "bitter much" I felt like beating her right there to a bloody pulp. Dana was her good friend for years. She was acting like a real bitch. and says to Lauren about Dana "she's just pissed I don't sit with her at lunch anymore". So her popularity with a group of troubled "unclassy" girls was more important than one real friend. Karma got her back and as I said she should have known Lauren was going to check Dana's wall. she was two face.

6. She kept fueling Kristin's and Lauren's hatred towards her with her smart mouth and should have known Alexa would choose Kristin and lauren over her any day. If the whole group kept fighting Alexa would have dumped her anyways.

7. If you want to talk *beep* about people don't go and befriend them when you have the chance just to be popular (lame)

8. Even when she saw the phone camera running and knew something was not right she argued with the girls and screamed "how am I a whore?" instead of just trying to get out of there. She was asking for it.

9. Most importantly, she should had enough common sense to figure out why Alexa was pissed, Dana's wall on face book after Lauren just got through asking her about it ...Alexa warned her if she comes over the house Kristin is going to beat her ass and she will not stop her. She still goes there.

She acted like she was better than all those girls except for Alexa and was even upset Alexa was meeting them too at the lake during spring break. She had a bitchy attitude and was doing anything to conform to a group of troubled girls. she got what she deserved.


she was acting like a real bitch and it took the girls beating her for her to be nice again and humble and not care about popularity? pathetic

reply

1. She was too desperate to be popular and even began to be mean to her little sister, disrespect her parents and be disobedient. Imagine if she continued to be popular how unruly she would have become to her parents?


She was struggling to fit in and be accepted by her peers. This isn't uncommon with kids. Also, teenagers are often moody, disrespectful, and disobedient. It's because they are trying to be adults and have freedom without paying attention to the responsibility that comes with that freedom. They like to think that being an adult means that I can do whatever I want with no consequences. They are right smack in the middle of childhood and adulthood and are trying to find their place in the world.

2. She dumped and ignored her best friend to be with a clique.


She ignored her best friend in order to be accepted into the clique which is also an unfortunate reality. It's very sad actually. However, I don't think it warrants a beating so bad it leaves permanent damage.

3. She had no right saying stuff at the lunch table like "not too classy either"...she already had a attitude towards most of the girls except for Alexa....And those girls picked up on it. she had a attitude with most of those girls from the start and only wanted to be friends with Alexa. Her attitude is what got those girls not liking her.


I got the sense that Alexa was the nicest girl in the group (that isn't saying much though). lol I felt that Alexa was faking friendship from the beginning just to have someone smart around to benefit her. I don't think Alexa ever cared about Haley or liked her at all. She just pretended to accept her for her own convenience.
About the "not too classy either" comment, Haley was just going along with what the other girls were saying without even really knowing what she was saying. Prior to her comment, another girl said something along the same lines so she was just agreeing with them to keep on being accepted. They blew that comment way out of proportion because they resented Haley from the beginning.

4. When Lauren asked Haley in the restroom "what does she mean Haley?" about Dana telling her she does not like any of the girls and after what she wrote about them on her face book wall. Haley should have known Lauren was going to log into Dana's page and check the wall and find it. She should have gone home and deleted those comments on Dana's wall asap.


I totally agree with that one.

5. She says to Dana after being cruel enough to dump her for a group of cliques "bitter much" I felt like beating her right there to a bloody pulp. Dana was her good friend for years. She was acting like a real bitch. and says to Lauren about Dana "she's just pissed I don't sit with her at lunch anymore". So her popularity with a group of troubled "unclassy" girls was more important than one real friend. Karma got her back and as I said she should have known Lauren was going to check Dana's wall. she was two face.


True. But I don't think it warrants being beat to a bloody pulp.

6. She kept fueling Kristin's and Lauren's hatred towards her with her smart mouth and should have known Alexa would choose Kristin and lauren over her any day. If the whole group kept fighting Alexa would have dumped her anyways.


Yes. Because Alexa was really never her true friend in the first place. She was just using Haley because she was smart and could help her get good grades and maybe try to copy her test answers.

7. If you want to talk *beep* about people don't go and befriend them when you have the chance just to be popular (lame)


She didn't befriend them. Alexa befriended her. In Haley's mind, it was just Alexa who was actually her friend. The other girls were Alexa's friends, not Haley's. Haley just barely tolerated them to keep up the friendship she had with Alexis. Or thought she had anyway.

8. Even when she saw the phone camera running and knew something was not right she argued with the girls and screamed "how am I a whore?" instead of just trying to get out of there. She was asking for it.


She really thought Alexa was her friend. Alexa also defended her down by the lake so she thought the same would happen at the house.

9. Most importantly, she should had enough common sense to figure out why Alexa was pissed, Dana's wall on face book after Lauren just got through asking her about it ...Alexa warned her if she comes over the house Kristin is going to beat her ass and she will not stop her. She still goes there.


I don't think Haley actually believed it when Alexa told her Kristin was going to beat her ass. Because Haley believed that Alexa was truly her friend (which she never was) she didn't think Alexa would actually let those girls harm her.

She acted like she was better than all those girls except for Alexa and was even upset Alexa was meeting them too at the lake during spring break. She had a bitchy attitude and was doing anything to conform to a group of troubled girls. she got what she deserved.


I don't think she thought she was better. She just liked Alexa. She didn't like Alexa's friends because they were mean girls.

reply

That's pretty bad victim blaming. Yeah, she was frustrating, not a great friend and did some very silly things. She was rude to her old friend and rude to those girls. But every teenager does things like that. That doesn't mean 5 people can beat them up.

reply

Seriously? She deserved to be beaten to a pulp which permanently damaged her hearing? She deserved to be videotaped while being beaten to a pulp? You and people who think like you do is what is wrong with this society. Physical violence (unless defending one's life) solves nothing. I have a feeling (or maybe I am just hoping) that you are very young and naïve.

She had the saddest look I've seen in years, A kangaroo cry ~ Blue October

reply

And you deserve to get your brain checked.
Are you really saying a young girl deserved to get beat nearly to death for a half an hour by five people because she was a little snooty sometimes and said "one" comment on the internet.
Lord have mercy on your soul.
I mean I seriously can't even process what you wrote because it is so disgustingly *beep* in the head.

reply

Are you smoking crack? That's basically the only thing that would make sense when it comes to your post.

reply

10. She has a 5 ft 10 in football shape driver/bodyguard that she allows to drive into the sunset. No shame in him escorting her in and when Amazon Blonde goes crazy, he could be like BOOOM, LOOK WHO STEPPED IN THE ROOM. Take that for my 200 lb cousin who you gave a fat lip.

reply

Wow, OP. You're justifying a terrible beating of a teen girl because she was making the same type of stupid choices that most teens make.

reply

The OP has to be an immature teen who needs to grow up. No person ever deserves to beaten like Haley was in this movie. She did nothing to any of these spoiled little b*tches that could provoke this incident. Alkexa was really the worst for allowing all the girls to savagely beat Haley. This was fiction but there was a similar incident in Florida where the girl who was beaten committed suicide. Did this girl deseve this fate too?

Try thinking before you post on these boards.

reply