MovieChat Forums > Charm (2013) Discussion > Man Bites Dog rip off.

Man Bites Dog rip off.


The title says it all. Check out the much better "Man Bites Dog" and compare for yourself.

When theres no more room in HELL the dead will walk the earth.

reply

I'm pretty sure that it was conscious. If you watch the movie, there's just no way Ashley didn't know of it, and probably wanted to pay homage to Man Bites Dog...to the point of excess, really.

But hey, the same thing could be said about Suzanne Collins when comparing the Hunger Games to Battle Royale. She claims she legitimately didn't know about it. Both are hard to believe, but not out of the realm of posibility.

reply

Eh, I'll stick with "hard to believe" on both.

When theres no more room in HELL the dead will walk the earth.

reply

There's *no* question this movie blatantly plagiarized Man Bites Dog. There are entire scenes lifted straight from that film, there are even shots and edits so similar, it'd take the faith of a fundamentalist to believe this wasn't, in essence, a sub-par remake of Man Bites Dog, with no credit. Adding insult to injury, scenes, wardrobe and props are stolen from Taxi Driver too!

This film, Random Acts of Violence, isn't even in the same league as the well crafted Man Bites Dog. Don't waste your precious time watching this witless, aimless film with consistently pointless dialogue, instead watch the original and far superior film.
Hell, Criterion had/has(?) a version!

The filmmaker should be ashamed of himself, his theft is not just blatant, but morally repugnant. Considering the director of Man Bites Dog committed suicide, if the creator of this "film" was actually 'paying homage' why not put "inspired by...", or "thank you to...'" or even "dedicated to the memory of..." the late director in the credits? If he had, I mightn't have been so irritated?
And lastly, please Ashley Cahill, don't insult the audiences intelligence by pretending you didn't plagiarize from Man Bites Dog.

reply

Man Bites Dog can suck it; that was one s**t film. Random Acts of Violence was definitely better.

reply

Man Bites Dog is garbage. While this film is no classic, it's much better than MBD.

reply

No, your opinion is wrong and stupid.

When theres no more room in HELL the dead will walk the earth.

reply

My opinion can't be wrong, you fool. It's an opinion.
And while you can certainly say that my opinion is stupid, your asinine post above gives me the strong impression that you, good sir, are the stupid one.

reply

MBD was excellent and ground-breaking for it's time.
This was pretty much unwatchable

reply