Thanks-I actually stumbled across this myself after I had posted-somebody has posted a list of the approximate locations of and products that each district produces-and the consequent contradictions and illogicalities (the Capitol{I've spelled it correctly this time around} has nuclear power, so why does District 12 mine coal, etc), but thanks for the effort anyway...
I've a problem with some of these lists, and have posted about them from time to time. Even though some are based on information now considered "canon" because of the movies, often they are at best just third-party guessing, and at worst contradict the books.
The problem is that the world-view of Panem in the books is incomplete: very few details are given WRT its geography, and the industries of some of the Districts are never revealed. This can be justified because the books are written from Katniss' POV, and she living in D12 has a fairly limited understanding of life in the rest of Panem (the Capitol deliberately keeps tight control on inter-district information), and she only tells us the reader what she thinks we need to know.
However when the films got the big-budget publicity treatment, they tried to fill in some of Collins' gaps, resulting in many of the "contradictions and illogicalities" you refer to.
Looking at the specific cases you mention:
1) As far as I recall, there's no mention of nuclear power in the books - at least not
officially. In the movie spin-off "Tribute Guide", D5 is described as being responsible for "electric, solar and nuclear [energy]", but IIRC the novels only refer to hydro (the dam attacked in "Mockingjay"). D13 had produced nuclear weapons before the Dark Days, but that had been done
in secret: officially it was only responsible for graphite mining (even more illogical than coal mining, of course, but it makes some sense when you consider it's only a cover).
2) IIRC, it's not made clear in the novels that D2 is largely responsible for Peacekeeper training until "Mockingjay". Again this is largely unofficial; D2's
official industry is masonry. After the First Rebellion and D13 secretly securing an uneasy independence, D2 became Panem's main military base, hence the "Nut". The movie publicity made this much more explicit with (IIRC) an online propo declaring D2 as the "Peacekeeper District" - something which definitely goes against the more secretive relationship implied in the books.
--
"So I've got bullets, but no gun. That's quite Zen."
reply
share