Hollowgast Holocaust


Never realised that before! Even when I read the books! No wonder Franklin brushed off Abe's stories as just fanciful tales about the holocaust. Nice touch by Ransom Riggs:) NOT that the holocaust is anything to joke about, but I'm just saying that it was a great technique to make both Franklin and the reader start to doubt Abe's stories until we actually meet the Peculiars.

reply

I had the same experience...never picked up on how similar they sounded in the books, heard the word in the movies and just went 'oh!'

reply

Me too! I read the first two books two years ago and then Library of Souls last year when it was published, so the Holocaust references there were not as fresh in my head since I don't think that they were as pronounced as they were in the film. However, the film's allusions to it brought it back and like you, I had that "Oh!" moment. ;)

"You better call my agent" "You don't have an agent..." "Then call my cable man!" - Bewitched (2005)

reply

The words are nearly identical and the setting was World War Two, I made the connection right away. Also implied was that the Holocaust transformed ordinary humans into monsters.

reply

From what I can remember, the Holocaust element wasn't emphasised as much in the books, whereas the connection is made clearer in the film.

Good for you getting the connection right away, but there's no need to talk down to me in that tone.

"You better call my agent" "You don't have an agent..." "Then call my cable man!" - Bewitched (2005)

reply

There was no talking down, just an observation. Sorry if you saw it that way.

reply

Sorry for taking it that way. I thought you were talking down to me but I see now that you were just stating that you understood it.

"You better call my agent" "You don't have an agent..." "Then call my cable man!" - Bewitched (2005)

reply

I actually rolled my eyes at that thinking "how obvious is that?".

Then again, I rolled my eyes quite a lot watching this. xD

reply