MovieChat Forums > Monsters: Dark Continent (2015) Discussion > animal cruelty in this one(dog) and hens...

animal cruelty in this one(dog) and hens get killed (for real)


so i was kinda shocked that they suddenly killed a dog.

and then had a close up of it for 10 seconds.

i hope it was fake.


and then the arabs kill a hen for real and you get to see it and everything.


i turned off the video then and will never see this garbage.

reply

Thanks so much for the warning! I and others appreciate it.

reply

you don't mind stuffing your face with KFC, but just don't show you how that chicken gets cooked on camera. also, we can show people gutted, heads blown off, spewing bile from the mouth and worse on screen, but you complain when shown the aftermath of a sci-fi version of a dog fight...

typical hypocrite.

reply

I came here to say exactly that. Killing for food (which is real) is not animal cruelty.

Give me a freaking break.

reply

"you don't mind stuffing your face with KFC, but just don't show you how that chicken gets cooked on camera. also, we can show people gutted, heads blown off, spewing bile from the mouth and worse on screen, but you complain when shown the aftermath of a sci-fi version of a dog fight... "

Lol! How the hell do you know who eats KFC on here?! And as far I'm concerned, I'd rather see stupid people blowing each other to bits than an innocent dog! Stop with the name calling!




reply

I don't think you should speak to your friend that way.

I mean, I assume the OP is your friend, right? That's how you know they're not a vegetarian and are constantly stuffing their face with KFC?

- - -

Whether they find life there or not, I think Jupiter should be considered an enemy planet.

reply

You chose to watch a movie where there was the potential to see any number of dead people and then get outraged over a dead animal. Doesn't say much for your standards.

Three things cannot be long hidden: the sun, the moon, and the truth.

reply

How many times does this have to be explained to people like you? Dear god, you come on going, "WAAT, U NOT UPSET ABOUT PPL BUT U R ANIMALS LOLOL WAT!" and you actually think you've got the logical and rational high-ground. You don't. Here are only a few reasons why your dumb mocking of people who are concerned for animals is dumb:

One: A person in a movie is a paid actor/extra. If a PERSON is screaming as someone guts them, you can be pretty sure they are acting. If a dog is yelping or screaming as someone guts them, you're not entirely sure if the dog is acting are you? Because it's a dog after all, and scumbag humans don't value them and don't mind hurting them for effect. They could actually BE hurting that dog, for "art." Additionally, the dog can't go to a lawyer afterwards and have you sued because you abused it during filming, because it can't speak. This is reason one it is reasonable to worry about animals in films.

Two: I haven't watched the movie yet myself, but Wikipedia says parts of it were filmed in Jordan. I'm pretty sure it's illegal for them to murder people for movie-making, but animals? Taking into account that their cruelty-to-animal standards may not be all that great, it's completely rational to be worried that animals in the movie may ACTUALLY be getting harmed or killed. This is reason two it is reasonable to worry about animals in films.

Three: As a human being with feelings, it makes complete sense to just be more concerned overall in reality with an animal's well-being than a person's. This is a person's world. We made it and we understand it. Animals however don't, for the most part. A bird can understand and try to avoid getting hunted by a cat or a bigger bird (and this is why the "YOU EAT KFC DON'T YOU?" argument from the other idiot is invalidated: We are predators), but it can't be expected to understand that if it stands on a seemingly-harmless exposed wire it will die of electrocution. So it makes sense to feel bad if animals are hurt or abused in our world, because it is an unfair one, and humans generally have a thing about fairness in our thinking, rational minds. (Not you apparently, but most people.)

We've bred all their natural instincts out of them to be fearful of us and instead made it so that we (their predators) are trustworthy caretakers to them. Thus when we take that trust and abuse it (hurting and murdering a domesticated dog or cat or pig, etc.), it is far more tragic and dishonorable than it is hurting another human, who can see and understand such betrayal and even expect or protect themselves from it.

Do you think it's worse in movies to see a child, or someone mentally retarded perhaps, abused by a more-intelligent adult than it is to see an adult hurting a regular adult? I would think so. I mean for most people anyway. The child or mentally-handicapped person can't understand or quantify it, and so the act is more vicious and evil than it might regularly be. That's the same reason people doing crap things to animals is often much more horrific and evil than it is people doing crap things to people. It's unfair, it's dishonorable.

The fact that you couldn't come to any of these conclusions by yourself doesn't say much for your standards.

- - -

Whether they find life there or not, I think Jupiter should be considered an enemy planet.

reply

The shot of the dog was 3 seconds, not ten; you thought it might have been a real dead dog?! Wow. Why did you even post?

reply

the only cruelty here was what the filmmakers inflicted on the unsuspecting audience

reply

You sir or madame win the internet

reply

Interesting, as the movie is about how people deal with what they don't understand. In that universe the 'monsters' were killed in all kinds of ways yet because another life form is not accepted, no one was upset over it.

And yes, you can walk into any live poultry store, pick out a chicken, and have her killed, blooded, defeathered, cleaned, and cut up while you watch and they will probably let you video it. Was the op upset because the chicken was killed or because it was shown in a movie?

reply

Yep, you can't throw a rock without hitting a "live chicken store"

reply

I was at the live chicken store the other day (you know....making another home movie), I tried to choose this big ol hen, guy was like "No...sorry....that one has already been claimed!" I said "why's it still out here then?" Guy says "The customer just went to get his phone to record the preparation process!". So I had to settle for this OTHER hen. Don't think I wasn't pi$$d though! Because I WAS!
Next time I'm going to the other live chicken store, it's a little farther away, but it's worth it!

reply