Please comment.
and whoever is saying that this is better than Khuda Kay Liye is a sad tard.
There are alot and i mean ALOT of points i want to talk about but this movie in general is a fail.
Khuda Kay liye is such a nice movie that i have seen it multiple times. So that masterpiece/movie doesn't even deserve to be compared to this atrocity.
End rating 5/10.
I also liked khuda kayliye more than bol, but saying that bol in general is a fail wouldn't be correct. Please do share the points you want to discuss, and I request you to refrain from using statements like "whoever is saying that this is better than Khuda Kay Liye is a sad tard." Everyone has their own opinion, criticizing like this isn't healthy. Thank you.
I strongly disagree... It's damn of the best movies i've ever seen...
shareNot only Fail movie but *beep* movie...
What a Bakwas movie, it gave me shudder.
Mistakes in the movie:
Movie is too wrong ideally, and theme is misleading.
1. Panga with God. No matter what ideas you follow and interpret God's work, it'll be always controversial. Good movie makers don't do this, and if they do, then they also show the equal opposite side's perspective as it remains balanced. (Movie creates religious controversial)
2. Panga with Parents. The people who are most respectable specially in Islam. And the movie says they are *beep* they do biggest crimes/sins when they bear you. Its totally cheap idea, no matter in which society you bring this idea, they will point a finger on you.
3. Movie starts with a child born, who is intersex, so it becomes center character. but just middle of the movie he is killed by his 'religious' father! So the center character's story ends at the middle of the movie.
First thing the movie from the very beginning makes and creates an interest for audience in this boy. and when he is killed in the middle of the movie then what... what is the focal point to watch the movie?
And also he's killed by his own 'religious' father - which is again very un-natural, if he would be killed by abusers then it'll be much better as a story, but even in this case story should be revolved around him till end.
4. They are 14 siblings, but in the movie they show only 4-5. (very un-professionalism)
5. One dialogue "Larka Hame Syed Chahiye Per Ho Ahle-Sunnat", very strange! was it necessary to include "Per Ho Ahle Sunnat !!!?? again making things controversial.
6. Film makers make big conflicts between Shia Sunni by some dialogues and characters. It shows the immaturity of Film Makers.
7. in the end a girl (who killed her father) says, "i revenged my father to bore me", :D, what a stupid idea they give to world.
8. "Sirf Marna Hi Kyon Jurm Hy Peda Karna Kyo Nahi", its worth laugh!!!
I think you either have a problem in accepting the world around you or you are too naive to realize what is happening around you. The characters you saw in the movie are an actual depiction of our society. It is not the movie that is making a mockery of Islam, it is us, our society which is, and that is precisely what has been shown to you.
Fourteen wasn't the no. of children alive, it was the no. that were born, but only 8 survived out of them.
This Movie is a perfect Art movie
On IMDB 2200 ppl vote and rate this movie 8.1 shows in general its a hit in public
1. I think so you take these controversial matter personal.
or something associated to you.
2. I think so face the truth usually our society face such problems.
3. Killing Saify in the mid og film is quite accurate. and you are wrong saify is not the central charactor of movie.
4. If hakim sahib has done what they have showed in movie. then such a person should be killed.
5. No where Religion is hurt. (Wrong follower were criticized)
6. I think you never used to watch Art Movies thats y its not of your taste.
7. Y people do the same, what they hate watching people doing. Like hakim sb married to a Shia and Tawaif. the same thing her daughter demanded to marry with shia person.
Hakim sb Firstly shows himself a very religious person and hated his son, daughter even wife, did every crime, theft, Zinna, murder, bribery, lie, beat his children and wife. He personally is commented every sim.
Such a nice concept ..........
Qol-o-Fail ka tazad .... Hippocracy ........
[deleted]
This Movie is a perfect Art movie
On IMDB 2200 ppl vote and rate this movie 8.1 shows in general its a hit in public
1. I think so you take these controversial matter personal.
or something associated to you.
2. I think so face the truth usually our society face such problems.
3. Killing Saify in the mid og film is quite accurate. and you are wrong saify is not the central charactor of movie.
4. If hakim sahib has done what they have showed in movie. then such a person should be killed.
5. No where Religion is hurt. (Wrong follower were criticized)
6. I think you never used to watch Art Movies thats y its not of your taste.
7. Y people do the same, what they hate watching people doing. Like hakim sb married to a Shia and Tawaif. the same thing her daughter demanded to marry with shia person.
Hakim sb Firstly shows himself a very religious person and hated his son, daughter even wife, did every crime, theft, Zinna, murder, bribery, lie, beat his children and wife. He personally is commented every sim.
Such a nice concept ..........
Qol-o-Fail ka tazad .... Hippocracy ........
such movies are high rated (better say over-rated) because no else watch them, only people of their own county watch them and they for some reason (due to related with their own country) they 'blindly' like them.
Just labelling the 'Art' movie does not make it 'good' automatic.
my Rating : 0
from every aspect , Movie failed
1. in khuda kay liye the director depicts all the themes ie. fundamentalism,moderatism,terrorism,women's rights, music with much more sensitvity. whereas in bol he seems to be confused when he mixes homosexuality, prositution,inter-caste marriage while exploring a girl child's desire.
2. there were leading male protagonists in khuda kay liye like shaan and fawad whereas in bol atif played an "extended" cameo and amr kashmiri was murdered around the interval.
3.both rasheed naaz and naseeruddin shah did great job in supporting roles whereas in bol this was missing.
4. music of khuda kay liye even if not an oscar winning was much better than bol.
however bol's theme is as relevant as of khuda kay liye. the problems highlighted in this movie exists not only in pakistan or muslims but also in india and hindus. in fact the perfect example is bihar and u.p. where boys are still preferred more than girls and girls are often forced to prostitution.
P.S.- this is my personal opinion. i don't expect anyone to agree with me.
This Movie is a perfect Art movie
On IMDB 2200 ppl vote and rate this movie 8.1 shows in general its a hit in public
1. I think so you take these controversial matter personal.
or something associated to you.
2. I think so face the truth usually our society face such problems.
3. Killing Saify in the mid og film is quite accurate. and you are wrong saify is not the central charactor of movie.
4. If hakim sahib has done what they have showed in movie. then such a person should be killed.
5. No where Religion is hurt. (Wrong follower were criticized)
6. I think you never used to watch Art Movies thats y its not of your taste.
7. Y people do the same, what they hate watching people doing. Like hakim sb married to a Shia and Tawaif. the same thing her daughter demanded to marry with shia person.
Hakim sb Firstly shows himself a very religious person and hated his son, daughter even wife, did every crime, theft, Zinna, murder, bribery, lie, beat his children and wife. He personally is commented every sim.
Such a nice concept ..........
Qol-o-Fail ka tazad .... Hippocracy ........
I'm afraid you don't know what an "Art Movie" is. An Art Movie is one that is independent i.e not funded by a Major Studio and it is not aimed for the 'general public', it is in fact aimed for a specific niche of people. This film doesn't not full fill any of those conditions locally, yes if it were shown in limited release in places like America, then that would be another matter entirely, but as far as i'm aware of this film was produced by GEO and was seen by mass audiences in the country.
As for its Cinematic Values, I'm sorry this film has none in my opinion. If you want to watch a proper Art Movie, with real theatrical values, then go watch A Separation by Asghar Farhadi.
I have to agree that this is a complete failiture of a movie, but i don't believe that khuda ke liye was any better. Just because the subjects being discussed in the films are considered taboo in our society, doesn't necesserily mean that they have good production values.
share