MovieChat Forums > Fashion Star (2012) Discussion > Johana/Amber/Sylvia Should Still Be Ther...

Johana/Amber/Sylvia Should Still Be There


It's disgusting that the last three weeks have seen Amber/Johana/Sylvia go home when, honestly, they should have been the final four (along with Hunter).

What are the mentors thinking to put up Amber every week she's even eligible until they finally kick her off?

Then what are the buyers thinking (Macy's and Express) when they eliminate Johana over Cassandra? I can't remember one piece that Cassandra has designed, and yet she's in the final four?

Then there's last night's episode, when the judges/mentors made their dumbest decision yet in putting Hunter and Sylvia against each other guaranteeing that the best two left couldn't face each other in the finale.

What is so damn special about Jesse Ray/Garret, Cassandra, and the beloved-Daniel? Nothing. It's just the judges/mentors playing favorites to an absurd degree. They thought Johana was too fat/gaudy but she sold...then they hated her for being too commercial...then they hated Amber for "designing for her friends" whatever that means. It just feels like a very arbitrary, who-cares? season and it wouldn't surprise me if it was the last one.

reply

tonight was a joke, Sacks bought this hideous
outfit to keep Daniel on the show and send
those 2 guys home ,,,, tired of fixed, prescripted
reality shows

"You're watching too much Sopranos, when you give your kids their allowance in envelopes"

reply