MovieChat Forums > Won't Back Down (2012) Discussion > Honestly the child belonged in special e...

Honestly the child belonged in special ed (resource)


I work as an instructional aide for special education. I have worked with mild to severe students of all ages prek to grade 12 for the last 7 years now. Finally I'm getting my application together to get into the credential program to be a special ed resource teacher (mild to moderate disabilities). I honestly think the girl needed to be in special ed---resource. She had a mild learning disability that strongly affected her learning and how she processed. Maybe the funds weren't available but I disliked how the mom (Maggie Gyllenhaal) tried to pin it on the school system failing her when obviously she had an innate learning disabilty (dyslexia). She wasn't being given the individual attention she needed that special ed can provide and the work was not modified for her. To top it off, she was in a class full of ill-behaved children and the teacher was horrible needless to say who should've been fired. However, I don't think the teacher was the sole character standing in the way of her learning. I think her mom also was. Instead of fighting for her to have a better education and be at a better school, she should've been fighting for her to be in a smaller class and special ed resource. But then if she had done that the movie wouldn't have been the same.

reply

[deleted]

I think it's about the labeling and isolation. When I was in school I feel like there was a stigma to special ed. Like only the kids on the short bus... it had a very negative connotation socially. Now they want to label everyone as special ed. Then they grow up to be unproductive adults thinking they're slow or something. They say they can't work because they have a learning disability, which is virtually indiscernible. You get put in special ed for add, or just being a little behind, then the kids tease you and call you dumb... I don't see what's so hard about just providing a little extra tutoring to get people caught up. I taught at a charter school once where they had like a special math half hour and reading half hour where the class was broken up and the kids who were behind went with one teacher, the kids in the middle did one activity and the advanced kids did something else. They were only elementary aged but didn't seem to notice who the smart ones were in the division.



It weakens us to not give our enemies the respect they deserve...

reply