MovieChat Forums > Kumaré (2011) Discussion > His documentary should pay for his belie...

His documentary should pay for his believers' psychological counseling



After the Unveiling, I suspect many of the believers (unconsciously and to save face) will embrace Vikram. First, because they've already proven they are susceptible to outside beliefs (his now being Vikram) is another thing they can be accepting of. But secondly, to reject Vikram now is to reject the joy they felt accepting, and believing in, Kumare.

What Vikram did really is indefensible and, even though Vikram is a nice guy and Kumare didn't instruct his believers to do anything dishonorable. At the very least, he wasted their time. At the most, he psychologically traumatized these people. Imagine some of the trust issues these people must have later in life: "Who is this new person? Are they what they appear to be? Are they manipulating me?"

I do not like Vikram nor find his methods ethical. Not as bad as Stanley Milgram, but almost (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment). What's ironic is this "experiment" goes on all around us, with millions of Kumares on the planet professing their religions for which they have no real basis.

It's just that Vikram is probably the only one to start and end his religion knowing it was untrue and revealing it as such. (Imagine if Vikram and his documentary crew had died in a plane crash before the revelation: that could've been the birth of a whole new religion.)

reply

I think what he did took a lot of courage. Who knows how many people he has saved from falling for a real life cult or snake oil salesman. Those are the real people we should all be upset at. Also, this documentary showed that it's not just dumb, weird, or gullible people who fall for these sorts of things. Smart and accomplished people are also susceptible.

reply

i agree with theoffice11, this showed being smart and successful will not prevent you from being tricked by someone like this.

reply

When wasting someones time is considered as crime, I'll file a lot of lawsuits :)

Imagine some of the trust issues these people must have later in life: "Who is this new person? Are they what they appear to be? Are they manipulating me?"


These are questions that people should ask a lot more nowdays.

(Imagine if Vikram and his documentary crew had died in a plane crash before the revelation: that could've been the birth of a whole new religion.)


Agree, like every other religion in the world has started the very same way. People make stuff up.
----
I laugh at your opinions, and if Matrix was here, he'd laugh too.

reply

Vikram only wasted a month or two for these people. Organized religion wastes people's ENTIRE LIVES. That's the real crime.

reply